Tiptop Cat. By C. Roger
Mader. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. $17.99.
Monkey: A Trickster Tale from
India. By Gerald McDermott. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. $6.99.
Work, Dogs, Work: A Highway Tail.
By James Horvath. Harper. $15.99.
Daisy to the Rescue: True Stories
of Daring Dogs, Paramedic Parrots, and Other Animal Heroes. By Jeff
Campbell. Illustrations by Ramsey Beyer. Zest Books. $17.99.
Animals take chances for all
sorts of reasons – and they take them especially dramatically in books such as Tiptop Cat. This is the simple story of
a cat living in Paris and loving it – especially loving rooftop climbing that
eventually brings him to the tiptop of a chimney, where he sees the city spread
out beneath and all around him, the Eiffel Tower prominent amid the buildings
and streets. All is idyllic until an intruder appears in the form of a pigeon –
and of course the cat gives chase, leaps and pounces, but…uh oh…misses. And so he plunges down, down,
down, past bemused residents of several apartments, the cat showing very
human-like expressions of worry and concern, eventually falling right through
an awning and ending up looking cross-eyed in the arms of a shopkeeper. No harm
done: a visit to the vet shows no broken bones or serious damage. But the cat’s
spirit, if not his body, has been hurt, and now he avoids the rooftops, hiding
indoors in the laundry basket, under a blanket, behind curtains, beneath a rug.
Quel dommage! But this is not the end!
For soon another bird shows up – a crow, this time – and the cat’s instincts
lead him once again to give chase, this time from the apartment window, up and
up and up, until finally the cat is once more “on top of the world,” gazing out
over Paris, and hopefully having learned his lesson about leaping too far and
too fast (the crow perches on the chimney behind him, safely out of sight). C.
Roger Mader’s well-paced story and elegant, near-photographic illustrations
produce a picture book that is indeed mostly about the pictures, which offer a
series of entertaining perspectives on the cat, the birds, the people in the arrondissement, and the city of Paris as
a whole.
Gerald McDermott takes young
readers on a journey to Asia in Monkey: A
Trickster Tale from India, originally published in 2011 and now available
in paperback. Again, the illustrations are a big part of the book’s charm, but
these are ones befitting a fairy tale: created with textured paper and
hand-colored with fabric paint and ink. They give just the right “once upon a
time” feeling to the story of wily Monkey and hungry Crocodile – a fairly
typical trickster tale, in which Monkey wants to eat the mangoes that grow on a
mid-river island, but cannot get there; while Crocodile wants Monkey to try to cross the river so Crocodile can
eat Monkey’s heart. Crocodile offers Monkey a ride to the island, and Monkey
has to think quickly when Crocodile sinks lower and lower in the water and
announces that he is going to eat Monkey’s heart. Escaping from that particular
trap, Monkey looks for another way to the island, finding it in the form of
some rocks in the river on which he can jump. So Crocodile decides that he will
disguise himself as one of the rocks, and grab Monkey when Monkey jumps onto
him – and, again, quick-thinking Monkey has to find a way out of this fix. He
does so, telling Crocodile from the safety of the shore that “your teeth may be
sharp…but your mind is dull!” Monkey is one of many trickster characters from
around the world, from Br’er Rabbit to Anansi the spider, and his escapades
here fit right in with those of other physically-weak-but-wily heroes and
sort-of-heroes (tricksters are not wholly positive role models – witness, for
example, Loki in Norse mythology). Young readers will enjoy Monkey’s antics at
Crocodile’s expense, but hopefully remember that Crocodile is still in the
river, just waiting for Monkey to make one tiny mistake.
Mistakes are not acceptable
among the construction-crew dogs who appeared first in Dig, Dogs, Dig and then in Build,
Dogs, Build. Now Duke and the crew (Roxy, Buddy, Max, Spot, Spike, and Jinx
the cat mascot) are back in Work, Dogs,
Work: A Highway Tail. And this time they are building, as the title indicates,
a highway. Assembling their heavy equipment – bulldozer, grader, steamroller,
loader and paving truck – the dogs start their busy day, bulldozing and
smoothing, flattening and leveling the ground. Dump trucks pick up their loads
from “huge quarry trucks [that] are too big for the street.” Bit by bit, the
road work progresses, until the dogs are stopped by “mile after mile of
axle-deep muck.” No worries, though: “With hills on both sides,/ Duke knows
what to do./ ‘Get digging, dogs!/ We must tunnel through!’” They blast a
tunnel, proceed to a river, realize they “need a tall bridge/ at least four
lanes wide,” and promptly work with a barge crane to erect one. “Building this
bridge was/ quite unexpected./ It’s a very big job keeping/ places connected.” Eventually
the road is finished – yes, in one day, which is no more realistic (and no
less) than what happens in James Horvath’s previous dog-construction-crew
books. The road runs from the city, through the hills, “all the way to the
beach,” where the dogs get to take some well-earned time off before starting
their next job. The nearly zany pace of the construction contrasts with the
realistic depictions of equipment and accurate (if very brief) descriptions of
what needs to be done to accomplish each part of the road-building task. The
ever-diligent, ever-happy crew – with Jinx popping up here and there throughout
the project – always has a good time at work. And Horvath always has a few
visual surprises in store, such as the happy shark tapping Spot on the shoulder
as Spot, wearing a make-believe shark fin, watches Spike run away and thinks he is the one who scared his pal. The
rollicking rhymes and amusing pictures combine to make this book, like its
predecessors, wholly unrealistic as to the speed of construction – but wholly
enjoyable for imagining what it would be like if work could be done at this pace.
Fictional animals may be
particularly hard-working and dynamic, but real-life ones can at times even
surpass their make-believe counterparts in terms of bravery. Daisy to the Rescue is a four-part
compendium of stories of animals, domestic and wild, that have saved human
lives – perhaps intentionally, perhaps instinctively, perhaps coincidentally,
but saved them they have. The fourth section, “Legends and Folktales,” is
fascinating but largely dismissible by those of a scientific bent, and Jeff
Campbell knows this, which is why he labels this part of the book as he does.
It is nevertheless fascinating, and not wholly unverifiable: although the ancient
Greek tale of Arion being rescued by a dolphin is certainly not provable and
has many mythic features, the story of Sergeant Stubby, a dog in World War I
that participated in 17 battles, is certainly true – even if some of its
details may have been exaggerated. The meat of the book, though, is in its
first three sections. The first focuses on domestic animals living with humans
– companions that it seems logical would be especially aware of and responsive
to human beings’ needs. Dogs figure largely here, of course, but so do a
pot-bellied pig that managed to bring home a passing motorist after his owner
had a heart attack, a rabbit whose strange behavior alerted a woman that her
husband was in a diabetic coma, and a Quaker parrot that alerted a babysitter
that a little girl was choking by uttering the phrase baby “Mama baby” for what
the babysitter said was the first time ever – and with apparent understanding
of its meaning. Did the parrot
understand? Do any animals know what they are doing when they save human lives?
Do they act with intention, or instinct, or do we humans look back at events
afterwards and only think the animals
protected us? To his credit, Campbell asks these questions repeatedly, while
generally letting the anecdotes in the book speak for themselves. The second
section of Daisy to the Rescue is the
least interesting, because it focuses on animals that are specifically trained
to help people – although even here, some stories show the animals going well
beyond what they seem to have been trained to do. The third section, on wild
animals that have saved humans, is in some ways the most intriguing, since
there seems to be little evolutionary reason for undomesticated animals to help
human beings. Yet the stories are evocative of the tempting notion that perhaps
there is a sort of free-floating interspecies empathy that occasionally
manifests itself in animal aid to humans, just as some humans will go out of
their way to help animals with which they have no special relationship – ducks
or turtles crossing a busy road, for example. The first three stories in this
section involve two gorillas and a band of vervet monkeys, but before readers
can start thinking that perhaps empathetic assistance exists only between
humans and our distant simian cousins, Campbell tells about gray seals that
kept a woman afloat in freezing water long enough for a rescue boat to reach
her; a tame but not fully domesticated elephant that sensed an incoming tsunami
and ran from the shore with an eight-year-old girl on his back, standing still
and bracing himself when the wave outran him and slammed into him; Ethiopian
lions that scared away men who were abducting a 12-year-old girl and stood
guard over her until police arrived half a day later, at which point they
backed slowly away and left the girl with the rescuers; and more. The accuracy
of some of the book’s stories seems greater than that of others, and some of
the accounts are simply harder to believe – occasionally, someone observed to
have been rescued by an animal does not believe it ever happened, even though
witnesses say it did. So it is fine to read Daisy
to the Rescue simply as entertainment and to be skeptical of much of what
Campbell reports. But it is unlikely that all
the stories here are completely unfounded, and anyone who lives with companion
animals or interacts with wild ones is well aware that nonhuman creatures have
far greater depths to them than humans always give them credit for. Not all
animals are heroic, certainly, but some, it seems, are – and there is something
reassuring about the notion that maybe we humans are not the only creatures
that care, in times of distress, about what happens to us.
No comments:
Post a Comment