Brahms: Piano Concertos Nos. 1
and 2. Sunwook Kim, piano; Hallé
conducted by Sir Mark Elder. Hallé.
$29.99 (2 CDs).
Liszt: Berlioz Transcriptions.
Feng Bian, piano. Naxos. $12.99.
Schumann: Humoreske in B-flat,
Op. 20; Blumenstück in D-flat, Op. 19; Davidsbündlertänze,
Op. 6. Luca Buratto, piano. Hyperion. $19.99.
Gershwin: George Gershwin’s
Songbook; Jasbo Brown Blues; Impromptu in Two Keys; Three Preludes; Promenade
(Walking the Dog); Novelette in Fourths; Prelude (unnumbered); Prelude
(fragment); Melody No. 17; Rhapsody in Blue, solo piano transcription; Rialto
Ripples; Swiss Miss; Three-Quarter Blues; Two Waltzes in C. Maurizio
Zaccaria, piano. ÆVEA. $18.99.
The exceptionally high
quality of the up-and-coming generation of pianists comes across again and
again in highly varied repertoire, showing that virtuosi of whom moist
listeners will likely never have heard are the technical equals – and sometimes
the interpretative equals, too – of many of the great pianists of the past. The
consistency of these pianists’ performances is truly remarkable. Brahms’ two
concertos have been recorded so often, by so many superb and highly thoughtful
performers, that it is hard to imagine what someone new can bring to them. One
answer is in a splendid recording featuring Sunwook Kim and the orchestra that
now styles itself simply Hallé, on the
ensemble’s own label. Kim and conductor Sir Mark Elder here produce
performances of great sweep, dramatic tension, and exceptional lyricism. Kim is
actually capable of performing both of these huge concertos at a single
concert, as he did shortly after this recording was made: he is that confident,
that well-versed in Brahms’ style and expressive requirements, and (not to put
too fine a point on it) that durable. These concertos are enormously draining
physically, technically, emotionally and psychologically. Separated by two
decades by time of composition, they simultaneously display two very different
sides of Brahms’ musical personality and show the foundational elements that
remained unchanged throughout his life. They are wonderful works with some
striking similarities – in elements of the Adagio
of the first and Andante of the
second, for instance. And they also have substantial and obvious differences,
the first concerto being heaven-storming and enormous in scale, its three
movements lasting almost as long as the four movements of the second – while
the second has calm and Brahms’ famous autumnal warmth as its most salient
characteristics, plus some gorgeous cello writing in the Andante (with lovely playing here by Nicholas Trygstad). The fact
that Kim can surmount the technical difficulties of these works, while
impressive, is not what makes these performances exceptional, simply because
there are so many really wonderful pianists out there. What sets these
recordings on a very high plane is their poetry, the nuanced handling of works
that can easily sprawl, the control and propulsiveness that Kim, encouraged and
abetted by Elder, brings even to the longest movement (the opening one of
Concerto No. 1). These are readings to cherish, and they are even more
remarkable for reflecting the amazingly high quality of thoughtfulness as well
as technical skill possessed by Kim, who is all of 29 years old.
Feng Bian is the same age, possesses many
of the same technical skills, has considerable sensitivity of his own, but
comes across very differently on a new CD featuring Liszt’s transcriptions of
works by Berlioz. This is the 46th volume in an ongoing Naxos series
offering Liszt’s complete piano music, featuring various performers, and it is
one of the most interesting discs released so far. The distinguishing feature
of Liszt’s work here, and of Bian’s interpretations, is delicacy rather than
virtuosity. It is easy to forget, given Liszt’s famed technical prowess and the
enormous difficulties he wrote into his music (in a very different way from
those that Brahms wrote into his), that there was a highly sensitive side to
Liszt as well. And it is this side that Bian explores most thoroughly and
engagingly. The Dance of the Sylphs
from The Damnation of Faust, the Bénédiction et serment from Benvenuto Cellini, and the March of the Pilgrims from Harold in Italy are all given careful
and very lovely treatment by Liszt, and Bian brings out the pieces’ manifest
beauties in very involving and altogether winning readings. There are also
pieces here drawn from Symphonie fantastique,
including Marche au supplice – which
has an introductory section called L’idée
fixe before the march itself, and which requires more of the pounding
virtuosity for which Liszt is known. More interesting, though, is a work called
L’idée fixe: Andante amoroso d’après une
mélodie de Hector Berlioz, which uses the symphony’s famous recurring theme
as the basis for a lovely, fantasia-like work of warmth and gentleness, which
Bian handles with sensitivity and skill. The most-substantial pieces here are
Liszt’s transcriptions of two overtures, to King
Lear and Les Francs-Juges, but
these are actually less interesting than the shorter works on the CD. Berlioz
was a brilliant orchestrator, more adept and creative in that respect than
Liszt himself, and the piano transcriptions of these extended works simply pale
beside the originals. That is scarcely the fault of either Liszt or Bian, the
former bringing accuracy and understanding to the piano versions and the latter
offering strong interpretations with fine balance and flow. But it is the
more-delicate, more-sensitive portions of this disc that are more memorable.
There are quite a few other
twentysomething pianists of considerable skill; indeed, the field of piano
virtuosity is currently quite a crowded one, which bodes well for the next
several decades of music-making. A new Hyperion disc featuring Luca Buratto
clearly shows this pianist’s affinity for Schumann, especially in the Davidsbündlertänze,
whose many variations of style and mood Buratto clearly finds congenial: his
playing is now forceful, now subdued; now intense, now reserved. Indeed, if
there is a criticism of this performance, it is that it never quite settles
down: there is no sense of where the Davidsbündlertänze,
taken as a whole, are going. But that has as much to do with Schumann’s
Florestan/Eusebius duality as with anything in Buratto’s playing, which is
skilled and sensitive throughout. Buratto’s handling of Humoreske and Blumenstück
is impressive, too: this is one pianist who really throws himself into
Schumann’s differing musical styles, so that the quiet and tender portions of
these works contrast especially strongly with the stormy and passionate ones. Buratto
shows a kind of easy virtuosity here, accepting the difficulties of the piano
writing without making it sound as if he has any difficulty surmounting them.
The result is a disc that focuses on the impetuosity and pronounced contrasts
of these Schumann pieces rather than on the pianist himself – an unusually
mature approach, and one that suggests a core sensitivity that should serve
Buratto well as his career progresses.
Some of that same
sensitivity is evident in Mauricio Zaccaria’s playing on a new ÆVEA disc whose repertoire is more
unusual than that offered by Buratto. Zaccaria here plays essentially all the
published piano music of Gershwin, a composer noted in particular for one
piano-and-orchestra work, Rhapsody in
Blue, but not otherwise thought of as a typical focus for pianists. There
is something of a crossover feeling to this CD, which is scarcely surprising:
Gershwin was a crossover composer, straddling the worlds of classical, jazz and
popular music and refusing to be pigeonholed in any of them. The extended Songbook of 1932, broken up into three
parts in this recording, includes 18 tunes that are often instantly
recognizable as vocals but rarely heard as pure piano pieces, including such
standards as I Got Rhythm, Strike Up the
Band and Oh, Lady Be Good. There
are also individual arrangements here, including Jasbo Brown Blues from Porgy
and Bess, the Promenade from Shall We Dance, and Merry Andrew from Rosalie.
But the pop-music side of Gershwin is only part of what Zaccaria explores. He
makes no attempt to turn the songs into anything profound, but he contrasts
them strongly with, among other pieces, the Three
Preludes from 1926. These show, individually and collectively, that
Gershwin could and did write strictly classical music – and very well-made
classical music, too – when he so chose. There are some other treasures here as
well, notably Impromptu in Two Keys,
which has the right hand in C and the left in D-flat. As for Rhapsody in Blue, it is interesting to
hear it in Gershwin’s solo-piano transcription, but this version does no more
justice to the piece than Liszt’s versions of Berlioz’ opera overtures do to
those works. Someone who has never heard Rhapsody
in Blue would find the solo-piano work intriguing for its combination of
solid understanding of classical form with freewheeling thematic development
and well-chosen harmonies. But anyone who has
heard this piece in its version for piano and orchestra will find it diminished
here, curiously flat and altogether less convincing than in its better-known
version. Zaccaria plays it well – he plays all this music with plenty of skill
– but there is simply less of interest here than in other works on the disc.
Still, Zaccaria, like Kim, Bian and Buratto, is already a considerable pianist
and one whose future development is sure to be worth watching and hearing.