Bean Stalker and Other Hilarious
Scary Tales. By Kiersten White. Illustrations by Karl Kwasny. Scholastic.
$16.99.
Even Fairies Fart. By
Jennifer Stinson. Pictures by Rebecca Ashdown. Harper. $17.99.
Paddington Goes to Town. By
Michael Bond. Illustrated by Peggy Fortnum. Harper. $9.99.
Fairy tales have spoken to
readers – and, before widespread literacy, to listeners – for uncounted
generations, and still do so both in their original forms and in contemporary
variations. Most were not stories for children but explanations of the way the
world works and warnings about it. And many were very frightening, as readers
of the collections by Charles Perrault and the Grimm brothers can easily
discover by tracking down and reading those groupings’ original versions. The
stories have been significantly toned down for younger readers’ consumption –
even later editions of the Grimm tales did some of this – but nowadays often
exist in separate versions for adults (emphasizing and even accentuating the
stories’ darker side) and children (keeping things light). Kiersten White’s Bean Stalker and Other Hilarious Scary Tales
stakes out (so to speak) a kind of middle ground, being intended for
middle-school reading and aimed at providing a certain number of rather
ick-inducing incidents mixing mild scariness with offbeat humor. The book’s
cover, by illustrator Karl Kwasny, does an unusually good job of encapsulating
White’s whole approach: leaves and vines from Jack’s beanstalk form the eyes and
nose of what looks like a scowling skull, with the turrets of a castle in the
background forming jagged-looking “teeth” and with traditional fairy-tale
characters, human and otherwise, appearing in the picture looking eerier than
they usually do in versions of the stories for young people. What White does in
the stories is create a kind of mashup “overview” narrative that she eventually
uses to connect a number of different tales – and within the individual
stories, she makes things creepy and/or gross and/or funny in ways that allow
her eventually to bring the whole book to an interrelated-tales climax. White
is also fond of puns: in the very first story, a variation on the tale of
Rapunzel, “let down your fair hair” sounds just like “let down your fair Herr,”
which turns out to make a great difference to the hapless prince and also to
the narrator, who points out the importance of proper spelling. White
introduces each tale with a suitably modified little poem: this story of Snow White starts with “one, two, buckle your shoe,”
in a version that ends, “nine, ten, something’s hungry again.” And there is
plenty of snarkiness as well: in the same story, the narrator comments that the
queen who wanted a baby must not have spent much time around babies, because
“they smell bad, they throw up a lot, and they cry instead of sleeping.” On and
on the book goes, through “The Princess and the Pea” (in which the spelling of
the final word turns out to matter quite a lot), “Little Dead Riding Hood,”
“Cinderella” (here called “Cinders and Ashes” and ending even before the fairy
godmother shows up, then starting again to be sure she is included) – and so
forth. The typical evil stepmother turns out in this book to be as close to
heroic as anyone or anything does: she “had devoted her life to putting out fires,”
sometimes metaphorical ones and sometimes not. And the tales are enlivened
(sometimes en-dead-ened) not only by Kwasny’s pictures but also by occasional
fancy typography, such as that used to show the way the beanstalk grows after
the beans take root thanks to all the drool that comes out of Jack’s mouth
while he sleeps. Bean Stalker and Other
Hilarious Scary Tales is certainly a version of multiple fairy tales, and a
few nursery rhymes, unlike any other – and although it does not supplant the
old tales either for humor or for fright, it does a mighty good job of aligning
both the amusement and the scariness with the experiences and expectations of
young readers today.
One thing today’s young
readers apparently expect – or at least one that authors and publishers expect
them to expect – is frequent use of the word “fart” in stories and even in book
titles. Families that find the word offensive, or simply unnecessary when a
short phrase such as “pass gas” works quite as well, will have no interest in a
book such as Jennifer Stinson’s Even
Fairies Fart. But the book is not intended to shock (apparently even
extra-large lettering for this word, as on the book’s cover, is now
acceptable). Stinson’s underlying message is fine: fairy tales (at least as
directed at children) seem to show an ultra-perfect world, but in reality, life
is not like that. Really, a book of this type would be even better if aimed at
the pervasive forms of entertainment directed at contemporary children:
television, movies, YouTube, video games, etc. All these offer
hyper-unrealistic worlds in which natural bodily functions are either absent or
played for laughs. Stinson’s story and Rebecca Ashdown’s well-matched
illustrations try to meld humor and a degree of realism; but the emphasis is on
amusement, as on the inside front and back covers, which show fairies of all
colors, shapes and sizes emitting gas, and the front cover, which has one fairy
(who looks just like a little girl) sending out a cloud big enough to cover
almost the whole front of the book. The somewhat-serious message here is
presented after showing the perfection that usually appears in fairy tales: “It
all seems so amazing!/ Can’t we be perfect too?/ If we wish on the brightest
star,/ could all this stuff come true?” The answer, of course, is “no.”
Perfection is unattainable, and even fairies, Stinson says, do not have it. Nor
do other fairy-tale characters: a dragon is shown cheating at cards, a princess
picks her nose, an elf has a bathroom accident, “wizards mope and pout,” witches
whine, “monsters sometimes want their mommies,” and so on. These shortcomings are
not important, according to Stinson’s writing and Ashdown’s illustrations. All
sorts of bodily functions, all sorts of less-than-perfect behavior, are simply
normal, no matter what fairy tales may say and no matter what they omit. “And
who cares?” asks Stinson. None of this stuff matters – it’s fine to love and
enjoy fairy tales, and by extension to love and enjoy all the kids who play
“let’s pretend” and who themselves like fairy-tale stories, even in the
knowledge that perfection does not really exist anywhere. That is a fine and
uplifting message, and one that parents will be glad to pass along to their
children. Whether this specific book, using this specific language, is the best
way to do that, will be a matter for individual families to decide.
The fairy-tale world of
Paddington Bear is scarcely perfect, but the late Michael Bond had no need of
bodily-function words or any sort of strong language to provide joy and
entertainment to young readers and equally enchanted adults for more than half
a century. Paddington Goes to Town
dates to 1968 and is the eighth collection of Paddington’s adventures to be
published (the first came out 10 years earlier). Now available in a new
edition, Paddington Goes to Town is
not officially a memorial to Bond (1926-2017) but will feel like one to
Paddington’s many fans. Its seven stories of curiosity and misunderstanding are
entirely typical of tales in the Paddington canon. The first, in which
Paddington is an usher at a wedding, is especially amusing. “Mr. Brown wasn’t
overenthusiastic about weddings at the best of times, and the thought of
attending one at which Paddington was lending a paw filled him with foreboding”
– a suitable feeling, as things turn out. Also here, Paddington tries golf,
mistakenly visits a psychiatrist at a hospital and causes considerable verbal
confusion, rolls a boulder down the aisle of a bus, and has several
opportunities to display the “very hard stare” that he had “when he liked.” Peggy
Fortnum’s illustrations perfectly encapsulate all Paddington’s expressions,
both the facial ones and his body language. Charming and gentle errors in which
Paddington behaves like an inquisitive human child are Bond’s stock-in-trade in
all the Paddington books, as is language that, while simple and easy to follow,
does not talk down to its intended young readers. The language is certainly not
as direct or crude as in many recent books for young readers – indeed, even
Bond’s 21st-century books retained old-fashioned sweetness and
verbal sensitivity. There are occasional British expressions that may take some
getting used to for Americans, but the writing will just as likely add to the
stories’ overall charm: “Altogether he was thankful when at long last he peered
round the side of his load and caught sight of a small queue standing beside a
familiar-looking London Transport sign not far ahead.” Paddington Goes to Town is as good an introduction to the bear from
Darkest Peru as any other of Bond’s collections: the stories are all
independent, and the bear’s personality shines through in them all. The pleasantries
of Bond’s urban fairy tales are a continuing source of joy, and it is easy to
imagine these stories still being found quite delightful when books featuring
cruder language and characters have been supplanted by the next new or faddish
creation.
No comments:
Post a Comment