maggie and milly and molly and
may. By E.E. Cummings. Illustrated by Marcia Perry. Pomegranate Kids.
$14.95.
Sheep Go to Sleep. By Nancy
Shaw. Drawings by Margot Apple. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. $16.99.
The Owl and the Pussy-Cat. By
Edward Lear. Illustrated by Paul Galdone. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. $8.99.
The Berenstain Bears: Hospital
Friends. By Mike Berenstain. HarperFestival. $3.99.
A simple but
thought-provoking poem written in 1956 by E.E. Cummings becomes a lovely
illustrated children’s book in the hands of illustrator Marcia Perry, who
downplays anything potentially scary or troubling while leaving the poem’s ambiguous
conclusion intact. In this brief story of four girls who go to the beach to
play, Cummings’ poem says what each one finds there. Maggie “discovered a shell
that sang/so sweetly she couldn’t remember her troubles,” and Perry actually
shows notes, not the sound of the ocean, coming from it – after all, Cummings
does write “sang.” In the poem, the sudden reference to “troubles” is slightly
jarring, but here Maggie is simply smiling gently while holding the shell to
her ear. Milly “befriended a stranded star,” and that is just what Perry shows
Milly doing – but, again, Cummings darkens the scene more than Perry does,
because the sea star is in fact stranded,
and that is scarcely good news for a sea creature. Molly has the strangest
experience of all: Cummings says she “was chased by a horrible thing,” the
exact nature of which he does not explain. Perry takes the fear completely out
of this by having the “horrible thing” simply be a not-at-all-horrible crab,
and showing that Molly seems to be walking quickly away (but not running) while
looking mildly discomfited (but not frightened). May’s experience speaks as
clearly to her personality as Maggie’s does to hers: May takes home “a smooth
round stone/ as small as a world and as large as alone.” That is quite a
concept for young readers – but Cummings did not write this as a poem for
children, even though it is a poem about
children. “It’s always ourselves we find in the sea,” the poet concludes, and
that final, thought-provoking line has meaning that goes well beyond Perry’s
final picture of the four friends sitting on the shore, arms around each other,
gazing at a passing pod of dolphins. By turning maggie and milly and molly and may into a children’s book, Perry
lightens the story considerably, even as she brings young readers to poetry
that they have likely never heard or read; and surely some children will pay enough attention to the words here to
discover the disparity between them and the comparatively superficial, pleasant
art. That can become the start of a voyage of discovery, in which young readers
learn that poems can say and mean a great deal more than they appear to on a
strictly surface-level basis.
Nancy Shaw’s poems about
sheep, on the other hand, are as lighthearted and amusing as can be, and are
not intended to do anything but amuse. Sheep
Go to Sleep, the eighth book in the series, follows the pattern of the
others very well indeed: the five sheep have a slight, amusing adventure, aided
in this case by a helpful sheepdog – a “trusty collie,” as Shaw puts it. The
sheep are having trouble falling asleep, giving the collie plenty of chances to
set things right – as Margot Apple’s illustrations show with their usual charm.
One sheep wants a hug, which the collie provides; the next asks for a drink of
water, then goes to sleep after the collie brings it; the third snoozes after
listening to a lullaby (the collie’s “singing” expression is especially
delightful); the fourth wants a teddy bear, so the collie brings his to share;
and the fifth wants a quilt, which the collie, by now quite tired himself,
provides. So all the sheep sleep – having some delightfully drawn dreams, too –
leaving the worn-out collie to find his own place for some well-earned rest.
Gentle rhymes, pleasant pictures and a wholly enjoyable bedtime message combine
to make Sheep Go to Sleep just as
much fun as the other entries in this always-pleasing series.
If the sheep are modern
classics, the owl and pussycat are very old ones – dating to Edward Lear’s 1871
book, Nonsense Songs, Stories, Botany,
and Alphabets. These old characters were done up in fine, then-new style by
Paul Galdone (1907-1986) in a version originally published posthumously, in
1987. Nearly 30 years later, Galdone’s pictures retain their vivacity and
charm, starting when the owl and pussycat get a wonderful “bon voyage” send-off
from a whole crowd of owls and pussycats standing on a dock; continuing as the
two characters (wearing hats that say “HMS Nonsense”) interact with fish while
singing along to a guitar tune and eating honey; and then leading to the
characters’ eventual arrival after “a year and a day” in “the land where the
Bong-tree grows.” Galdone shows that particular tree sprouting small drums and
drumsticks from its branches – and he shows the “Piggy-wig” standing on the
shore as being, indeed, a pig wearing a very elaborate wig (and having the
requisite ring in his nose, to be purchased for a shilling and used for a
wedding). So owl, pussycat, pig (as witness) and turkey (as suitably garbed,
book-carrying minister) all gather for a marriage celebration, and Galdone
shows their feast of mince and quince quite delightfully – even giving an
accurate portrayal of the “runcible spoon” with which the characters consume
the food. The final pages of dancing “by the light of the moon” include the pig
as drummer, a couple of starfish holding appendages, a just-surfaced whale, and
a smiling full moon – all in all, a seaside scene quite different in intent,
appearance and significance (or lack thereof) from that of maggie and milly and molly and may, occurring in a night quite
different from that of Sheep Go to Sleep,
and proving itself as wonderful in its way as the other books are in theirs.
A book with a more-serious
purpose, The Berenstain Bears: Hospital
Friends features the modern-classic Bear family in a story that, as happens
frequently in the Berenstain tales, is just a bit too upbeat and bouncy to be
believed. Mike Berenstain has the family visit the hospital where Cousin Fred
has just had a tonsillectomy – but the first thing kids will notice is that
everyone in the corridors is smiling (including, of course, the title
characters). The intent, to be sure, is to show young readers that hospitals
are not scary places – but they are serious
places, and the story downplays that to too great an extent. The smiling family
doctor gives the Bears a tour, starting with the “part of the hospital…where
cubs stay,” which is bright and clean and neat and features smiles on the faces
of every single cub, including the one in a wheelchair and the one with a cast
on a broken leg. The place looks like a particularly pleasant day-care center;
no wonder Sister comments that it “looks like fun!” Physical therapy also
features everyone smiling and enjoying their use of the rehabilitative equipment,
the X-ray area features a patient with a broken bone smiling and waving, and
even in the “room where nurses and doctors were getting patients ready for
operations,” everyone has expressions more appropriate for a day spa than a
hospital. The recovery room has postoperative patients all smiling, too, including
the ones who are asleep. Even the emergency room features calm, generally
smiling bears reading, writing or watching a big-screen TV. The Berenstain Bears: Hospital Friends
is so deeply unrealistic that it is only because of its obvious good intentions
that it gets as much as a (+++) rating. Certainly there is no reason to alarm
kids ages 4-8 about hospitals or get into details about the very serious illnesses,
the severe injuries and the deaths that hospital personnel – and hospital
visitors – encounter all the time. But The
Berenstain Bears: Hospital Friends is ultimately counterproductive in its
attempt to whitewash the reality of what hospitals are and what they do,
because any child who has to go to a real hospital for any reason (as a visitor
or, although hopefully not, as a patient) is going to be led by this book to
expect something so different from reality that he or she will have a heaping
helping of cognitive dissonance on top of the discovery of just how far from
authenticity this tour of Bear Country Hospital really is.
No comments:
Post a Comment