No Nap Book and CD. By Eve
Bunting. Illustrated by Susan Meddaugh. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. $10.99.
Pinkalicious: Thanksgiving
Helper. By Victoria Kann. HarperFestival. $8.99.
The Berenstain Bears: Thanksgiving
All Around. By Mike Berenstain. HarperFestival. $6.99.
Short, cute and charming,
but potentially problematical for families with small children, Eve Bunting’s No Nap, first published in 1989 and
first released in paperback in 1996, is now available in the paperback edition
packaged with a well-read, nicely paced CD that offers the book in two separate
versions. In one, narrator Jan Staab simply reads the whole book through, with
the story enlivened by some Michael Moss music. In the other, the reading and
music are the same, but there are page-turn signals as well, so kids can learn
to read the book on their own by listening to Staab’s narration and turning
pages as she moves on in the story. That story remains delightful, from an
adult perspective: little Susie does not want to nap while Mom is out, so Dad
tries to come up with ways of getting her to rest: walking, dancing,
exercising, reading and more. Finally, Dad gets Susie to lie down with him, but
she keeps coming up with things that she wants him to get for her – which he
obligingly does. The end result is that exhausted Dad is the one who falls
asleep, with toys piled all over him. The text is simple and winning, and Susan
Meddaugh's watercolor illustrations bring the words even more enjoyably to life
as they contrast Susie’s wide-open eyes with her father’s increasingly sleepy
ones. This book-plus-CD offering is a delightful one on many levels – but there
is a catch. Young children – the package is aimed at ages 3-8 but will be most
attractive for ages 2-5 – may very well see the book as an instruction manual
rather than an amusing fictional story. Kids like little Susie do find ways to avoid naps, and all
children, especially toddlers and post-toddlers, are constantly on the lookout
for new ways to escape midday sleep – not realizing that the lack of a nap will
make them (and their parents!) cranky, uncomfortable and generally miserable
later. No Nap Book can easily be read
as a step-by-step guide to escaping nap time and making sure that a highly
tolerant parent, such as the father in Bunting’s book, simply cannot find a way
to get a young child to rest for a while. Doubt it? Then by all means get this
book/CD combo and turn your young child loose on it – he or she will surely
enjoy looking at and listening to it time and again, and eventually reading it
on his or her own. But don’t say you weren’t warned of the possible
consequences!
“Short, cute and charming”
are also the aims of some brand-new books featuring popular series characters,
and fans of those characters will enjoy these entries even though they are
rather thin both in size and in plot. Both Pinkalicious:
Thanksgiving Helper and The Berenstain
Bears: Thanksgiving All Around are, as their titles indicate, strictly
seasonal books; and both try to attract young readers with extras rather than
simply with stories – Victoria Kann’s book features stickers, a poster and
tear-out Thanksgiving place cards, while Mike Berenstain’s offers a flap to
lift on every page. As it happens, the added items are at least as interesting
as these particular stories. Pinkalicious:
Thanksgiving Helper is distressingly free of the title character’s usual
preoccupation with the color pink – although not entirely absent, it has very
little role in the tale, with the result that this becomes just another
family-in-autumn story. Pinkalicious and her little brother, Peter, try to help
their parents with yard work and kitchen duties, but make a mess of everything
they do until, finally, they set the table attractively (although incorrectly;
their ever-tolerant parents thank them profusely; and everyone sits down for
Thanksgiving dinner. The occurrences here are characterless – the same story
could be told with pretty much any central characters from kids’ books, such as
the Berenstain Bears. As it happens, though, The Berenstain Bears: Thanksgiving All Around is a different – but
still entirely ordinary – story. There is no Thanksgiving meal here at all, and
the only reason the characters are looking for a turkey is to allow Papa to
proclaim the bird “a fine, proud fellow” and give the Bear family a chance to
wish readers a happy Thanksgiving. Title aside, the story is seasonal, not
holiday-specific, showing the Bear family walking around and seeing nature
scenes, a pumpkin patch, farm work, a pond, and so on. The flaps do not reveal
anything particularly surprising: at the pond, for instance, Brother mentions
that there must be ducks, geese and swans nearby, and lifting the flap shows
ducks, geese and swans. A pleasant, meandering little tale, thankfully free of
the moralizing that too often gets in the way of Berenstain Bears storytelling,
The Berenstain Bears: Thanksgiving All
Around is a nice but not very notable entry in this long-running series.
No comments:
Post a Comment