Talk to Me First: Everything You
Need to Know to Become Your Kids’ “Go-To” Person about Sex. By Deborah
Roffman. Da Capo. $14.99.
Diary of a Parent Trainer. By
Jenny Smith. Delacorte Press. $12.99.
Information-packed but
stylistically irritating, Talk to Me
First is a thoughtful, chatty, intelligent discussion of human sexuality –
not just sexual issues to be discussed between kids and parents, but sexuality
from birth to adulthood, gender issues in everyday life, and more. Its primary flaw is the way sex educator Deborah
Roffman puts the information across: she is so determined to make her comments
non-threatening that she incessantly lapses into parentheses and irritating
stylistic quirks that interfere with her underlying seriousness of
purpose. She writes, “Install a virtual
bug zapper of your own that’s hypersensitive to the word ‘tween.’” And: “So you pick up your eight-year-old
son…” (why the “so”?). She calls a
section “Back to the Teakettle” and begins it: “You know the drill. Repeat after me, five times: sex, oral sex,
anal sex, sexual pleasure, S and M, ‘queef’ (sound created by an air pocket in
the vagina during intercourse), fart, tingly, pulsing, condom, nipples, orgasm,
erection, ejaculation, clitoris, labia, stimulation, semen, erotic. Just words, right? You can’t be a go-to person if you can’t say
them.” And again and again, she uses
parentheses just because she seems to enjoy them: “If girls (and boys) were to
make up new rules…” “(Teenage sex sells
– beware what you read.)” “Like Superman
in a phone booth (what’s a phone booth?)…”
“If they (and we) adjust well…” “They
will date (although the exact form will vary greatly from teenager to teenager,
community to community, and school to school)…”
“Fifth-grade ‘relationships’ are very short-lived (except for two of my
friends from grade school who’ve been together almost continuously ever
since).” The overly cute style,
undoubtedly intended to keep readers comfortable with the subject matter,
rapidly becomes off-putting, and that is a shame, since Roffman is so good when
she addresses subjects forthrightly and without the need to “cute-ify” them:
“Within the space of ten seconds – because that’s how long ejaculation takes –
[sexual intercourse] has the power to accomplish not one but three of the most
powerful things there are, all at the same time: (1) create new life; (2)
potentially take life away; and (3) change any number of people’s lives forever.” Interestingly, Roffman juxtaposes statements
like this – about the tremendous power of sex and sexuality – with ones
designed to make sex seem like no big deal, or rather like just an integral
part of everyday life. One of her best
chapters, “Affirmation: Our Children as Sexual Beings,” opens by stating that
people are sexual from birth – and explaining that the statement has nothing to
do with what adults usually think of as “sexuality.” Roffman points out that the sexual system is
present and demonstrably functioning in newborns and even in utero: “Each day or night, at ninety-minute intervals during the
brain’s natural sleep cycle, starting before
birth, penises become erect…and in females, the vaginal walls release
sexual lubricating fluid.” Roffman’s
point is not exactly to demystify sex – it is to show parents that it is
ever-present in kids of any and all ages, and can therefore be discussed with
children anytime, provided that the talks are done in age-appropriate ways (of
which she gives numerous helpful examples).
Roffman’s analyses are frequently very intelligent and clever, as when
she objects to a Family Guy episode
not because of its language, sexual elements and treatment of the mother, but
because of “the underlying assumption in the show, and often in our society,
that boys, by nature, are bad.” It is fair to ask about this book, “So Where
Am I Headed with All of This?” – an actual chapter subheading – because Roffman
throws out so many thoughts and ideas in so many ways. Where everything turns out to be heading is
toward a final chapter called “Practice Makes Proficient: Let’s Go Fishing”
(there’s that irritating style again), in which Roffman offers a series of
scenarios involving kids of both genders and various ages, then asks readers
the same four self-evaluative questions about each one. Parents who have absorbed the information in Talk to Me First will presumably be able
to handle these slices of reality with directness and without embarrassment; if
not, they will presumably need to go back and reread parts of the book. Roffman’s point is that for parents to be
“go-to” people for their kids, they first have to be able to go to themselves
for answers to difficult and sometimes uncomfortable questions. But, she argues, the questions should not be
unanswered or unanswerable – and that is a fine message to take away from this
book, even if it sometimes has to be pried away from the work’s less-than-endearing
style.
Roffman’s book will
scarcely be the first one causing parents to wish that kids came with an
operating manual. Children undoubtedly
have the same wishes about their parents – so Jenny Smith has written one. Yes, Diary
of a Parent Trainer, despite the tongue planted firmly in cheek, is a book
in which 13-year-old Katie Sutton offers other teens a user’s manual for
parents – everything needed to “achieve optimum performance from your Grown-Up
or Grown-Ups, undertake straightforward maintenance and repairs, [and] ensure
smooth operation, in most situations.”
Watch that “in most situations” phrase, though, since Katie soon finds
herself dealing with a situation that her user manual doesn’t quite cover. From the standpoint of the novel, this is
both inevitable and something of a shame, since it nearly turns the book into
just another “Mom is dating someone and I need to break them up” piece of
fluff. “Stuart’s not a creep or a
monster,” Katie writes, but “it’s just wrong. Mum seeing someone.” Juxtaposing these very ordinary comments –
Katie’s mother is a widow – with ones about “operating” adults does lead to
some funny observations. “Your Grown-Up
is nonreturnable. The manufacturer
accepts no liability for their many faults. As they are probably, by now, slightly worn
around the edges and past their best, if not seriously damaged, don’t even
think of trying to get your money back. You cannot upgrade your Grown-Up. There
are no refunds and no exchanges.” The book is also enlivened with time stamps,
warnings (“when one Grown-Up goes into Reckless Mode, it can cause others to do
the same”), and “Sad but True Fact” observations, sometimes followed by a
“Useful Hint” or two: “It’s a horrible fact of life, but Grown-Ups snog
too. They take something that is
perfectly acceptable in young and attractive people and turn it into a
disturbing and tragic act. …If you find it hard to obliterate the image of the
kissing incident from your mind, try to replace it with another more pleasant
image – like trench warfare.” Katie
enlists help from her sister, Mandy, and brother, Jack, to get rid of Stuart, but
Jack kind of likes Stuart, and Katie soon finds that her prescriptions for
managing parents aren’t quite working out.
Not that she doesn’t try to be observant and attentive: “When a Grown-Up
goes into Sad Mode, it is usually because of something that has happened. …There are lots of clever things you can try,
like mode-switching and the Distraction Technique or a great big sloppy
cuddle…” It takes more than 250 pages
for Katie to realize that Stuart is “not someone who was wanting to take our
mum away from us” but “just another human being trying to get by in the
world.” Unfortunately, by the time Katie
has this revelation, her plan to get rid of Stuart is working all too
well. So there is an inevitable breakup
and an equally inevitable getting-back-together, and everything eventually ends
happily (at Christmas, no less) – all of which is unsurprising and also a bit
of a shame, since the sappy standardization of the book’s plot progress
interferes with its genuinely creative “user’s manual” approach. Despite everything, though, Diary of a Parent Trainer is fun, and it
is just offbeat enough to stand out from the many books that are similarly
plotted but lack an equally interesting foundational premise.
No comments:
Post a Comment