Widor: Piano Quartet; Amanda Maier-Röntgen: Piano Quartet; David Amram: Portraits for Violin, Viola, Violoncello and Piano. New York Piano Quartet (Elmira Darvarova, violin; Ronald Carbone, viola; Samuel Magill, cello; Linda Hall, piano). Urlicht. $19.98.
Eric Whitacre: Goodnight Moon; Lori Laitman: The Imaginary Photo Album; David Sisco: Dear God; Matthew Recio: Tales of Imagination; Juliana Hall: Songs of Enchantment; Evan Mack: Ode to Parenthood; Jason Weisinger: i carry your heart. Kathryn Leemhuis, mezzo-soprano; Samuel Martin, piano. BCM+D Records. $15.
The name of Charles-Marie Widor (1844-1937) is intimately associated with the organ but much less so with music for other instruments, so it is something of a surprise – an exceptionally pleasant one – to discover the many excellences of his A minor Piano Quartet (1891). It is a full-fledged Romantic work, its four movements overflowing with grand gestures and very considerable emotional evocations that, thank goodness, never turn completely maudlin. There is lyricism everywhere here, even in the broadly conceived and frequently intense opening movement, which repeatedly dips into solo or duo passages that often have a very pleasing level of piquancy. It is in the full-ensemble material, though, that the work and the New York Piano Quartet shine: there is a sense of building something grand here, further accentuated when the following Adagio shines forth as a love song whose sweetness is unerringly communicated in passages where upper string voices are delicately underlined by the piano. The third movement provides a welcome respite from all the emotive drama that has come before: quicksilver and bouncily upbeat, it has a dancelike feeling complemented by slower, graceful passages. The finale restores drama and sweep and a firm minor-key orientation that has nothing depressive about it but insists again and again on warmth and lyrical power. So impressive is the quartet both in its parts and in its totality that its unfamiliarity is surprising: highly skilled ensembles – and the New York Piano Quartet is certainly one – really should consider making it a regular part of their repertoire. They should also give considerable thought to the E minor Piano Quartet by Amanda Maier-Röntgen (1853-1894), the very last piece written by a composer whose longstanding ill health, early death from pleurisy, and life within the gender stereotypes of her time have obscured her many musical accomplishments. Pairing this quartet with Widor’s makes for some fascinating comparisons, since Maier-Röntgen’s also dates to 1891 and the two works share a four-movement structure whose flow is much the same. Their harmonic worlds and instrumental approaches, however, are not. Maier-Röntgen presses for more drama from the outset, and more forward-looking harmonies that are nevertheless firmly within Romantic-era expectations. Maier-Röntgen played Brahms’ piano quartets at her home, with Brahms himself on the piano, and her quartet certainly has Brahmsian influences, but it would never be confused with a work by Brahms himself: the clarity of individual lines and striking use of chordal passages (notably in the Andante) give the music considerable individuality. There is a pleasant touch of joviality in the third movement before the finale opens with a broadly conceived Largo espressivo that is very expressive indeed, after which an Allegro vivace sweeps away any lingering clouds in a series of ebullient gestures featuring especially delicate piano figurations and a coda that tests the mettle of the ensemble – a test that the New York Piano Quartet passes with flying colors. These two deeply Romantic works are accompanied on a beautifully recorded Urlicht CD by a late-20th-century piece called Portraits, by David Amram (born 1930). The inclusion of this work from 1979 with two from 1891 is not as arbitrary as it might seem. Portraits is in a single extended movement designed to give each instrument in the quartet solo material to highlight its technical and, more importantly, emotive capabilities. Since Amram’s musical language is by and large comparable to that of Widor and Maier-Röntgen, this chance to focus on the instruments and instrumentalists as individuals – after the two earlier quartets place more of a premium on ensemble playing – proves very welcome. The richness of the cello eventually gives way to some more-acerbic material in the higher strings: Amram is not beholden to compositional expectations of the 1970s, but neither is he immune to them. Furthermore, there are hints of Middle Eastern music here and there: Amram wrote the work after touring that region and was clearly influenced by what he experienced. But this is scarcely a folk-music-based piece: Portraits remains throughout an exploration of the communicative potential of each instrument in a piano quartet, periodically combining the voices so as better to emphasize their individuality. Amram’s work is not as immediately winning as the Widor and Maier-Röntgen quartets and to some extent is more rewarding for performers than for audiences. But the New York Piano Quartet plays it with firmness of tone and a sense of clear commitment that puts all the best elements of the music elegantly on display.
The stories told by the music of Widor, Maier-Röntgen and Amram are strictly musical ones, their connections with real-world events implied rather than overtly stated. In contrast, the narratives offered by seven contemporary composers and presented through the Boyer College of Music and Dance at Temple University in Philadelphia are quite overt and explicitly. Kathryn Leemhuis tells the tales in words while Samuel Martin underlines, emphasizes, expands upon and emotionally enlarges them on piano. What connects all the compositions is a focus on family and on child rearing – a topic at once familiar enough to provide immediate audience connection and broad enough to allow a wide variety of musical interpretations. The lullaby-like nature of Margaret Wise Brown’s Goodnight Moon is emphasized by Eric Whitacre. Lori Laitman’s The Imaginary Photo Album includes four portraits – musical photos, in effect – that open with feelings generated by an ultrasound and include an intriguing impression of listening to Peter and the Wolf with a three-year-old. Laitman’s music is a touch too emphatically art-song-like for the material, but David Sisco’s 12-tiny-movement Dear God keeps matters winningly simple in reflecting the words of children’s prayers in a delightful blend of sincerity and naïveté. The three-movement Tales of Imagination by Matthew Recio tries a bit too hard to encapsulate James and the Giant Peach, Alice in Wonderland and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, but some illustrative elements of the piano part are effective in illuminating elements of the three classic stories. Juliana Hall’s Songs of Enchantment are 10 settings of poems by Walter de la Mare, whose work is perhaps not entirely worthy of this level of attentiveness or of Hall’s attempts to use near-operatic vocals to convey material that is essentially simple and straightforward. Leemhuis, whose voice is adept, clear and well-mannered in most of the music on this CD, is somewhat wobbly here, and the amount of vibrato proves more a distraction than a form of emphasis. Certainly there are bits of enchantment here and there, as in the attractive piano pointillism of the musical feline portrait called Double Dutch, the skittering of Sillie Sallie, and the deliberately overstated drama of Alas, Alack! But the overall feeling is of over-complicating childhood matters that are, as parents know, already quite complicated enough. Evan Mack’s Ode to Parenthood makes those complexities quite clear: opening with pianistic scene-setting, it soon moves into appropriately musically underlined explorations of parental expectations vs. realities (“no one ever puts anything away,” “a two-year-old is kind of like having a blender without a top”). The amusing self-awareness, neatly escorted by the keyboard through the seven-minute song, is eventually connected with the sometimes ineffable joys that accompany all the frustrations. It is all a bit overdone, but then, so is parenthood. The CD concludes with Jason Weisinger’s i carry your heart (no-capitals titles are usually an affectation, but this one makes sense, since the words are by e.e. cummings). The simple declamatory setting stands nicely in contrast to the occasional over-elaborate complexities in some of the other works here, making for a suitably warm and thoughtful conclusion to an interesting program of modern art songs that individually and collectively explore family matters in sensitive and sometimes genuinely moving ways.
No comments:
Post a Comment