November 19, 2026

(++++) LESSONS FROM THE PAST

Music of the 17th-Century Avant-Garde: Biber, Muffat, Schmelzer, and Pavel Josef Vejvanovský. Agave (Aaron Westman, violin; Anna Washburn, violin and viola; Katherine Kyme, viola; William Skeen, cello and viola da gamba; Kris Kwapis, Baroque trumpet; Anna Marsh, dulcian; Kevin Cooper, theorbo; Henry Lebedinsky, organ). Acis. $18.99. 

Simone Molinaro: Fantasias for Lute. James Limerick Kerr, hybrid picking guitar. Acis. $18.99. 

     Today’s forward-looking composers tend to think that they have sprung into being fully formed, like Athena from the head of Zeus. Those that do acknowledge the existence of avant-garde thinking in the past tend not to go back very far – perhaps to John Cage, maybe even to Schoenberg, but that’s about it. What is intriguing about a new Acis release from the chamber ensemble Agave is that it focuses on much, much older avant-garde composers, only one of whom – Heinrich Ignaz Franz von Biber (1640-1704) – is reasonably often acknowledged as being ahead of his time. Even then, the tendency is to focus on Biber’s Battalia à 10 of 1673, with its extreme dissonance (reflecting the dissonance of war) and extended string techniques, and on the Mystery Sonatas, while paying much less attention (if any) to other Biber works that are equally outside the 17th-century mainstream. Agave shows that Biber’s forms of experimentation were more pervasive in his music than is generally acknowledged, by presenting four pieces that conform in some structural ways to 17th-century expectations but do not hesitate to explore harmonic and performance regions well beyond those typically associated with this time period. All the pieces – a Sonata à 5 in C and one in G minor, and a Partia in D minor and one in A – are solidly constructed and musically engaging on their own terms, with the Partia examples being especially intriguing because their multi-movement design and overall greater length allow Biber to explore emotional evocation in many ways and show that the extended techniques often present in his music are always at the service of its communicative quality. The four Biber works are interlaced with five other pieces on this very well-recorded CD, and in some ways those other works are even more interesting than Biber’s simply because they show that Biber did not create in a vacuum: other composers also pushed and probed the limits of the usual expectations of secular chamber music in the 17th century. Two of the other composers here may be at least somewhat familiar to audiences interested in this time period: Georg Muffat (1653-1704) and Johann Heinrich Schmelzer (c. 1620-1680). Muffat is represented on the disc by a Toccata that elegantly explores organ capabilities and by the four-movement Sonata No. 2 in G minor, whose gloom-pervaded opening gives way to some genuine jauntiness and subsequently to inward-looking, slow-tempo material and then an upbeat if scarcely rollicking finale. Schmelzer is heard in a one-movement Sonata à 5 in C that has a pleasantly martial air about it – and yes, it is possible to be pleasantly martial, which is just what this piece shows. Also here are two short but very well-made works by the very-little-known Pavel Josef Vejvanovský (c. 1639-1693): Sonata tribus Quadrantibus and Sonata à 4. The poise and ensemble balance of these brief pieces are notable, and the excellence of each individual member of Agave as well as that of the ensemble as a whole comes through clearly in both. Indeed, the performers are as thoughtful in their re-creation of this music as the composers were in their origination of it. For example, Agave uses a full church organ as a continuo instrument – and a modern one at that, dating to 1971 – instead of the simple, easily portable portative organ more often used in repertoire like this; but the organ is used carefully to provide connective tissue as well as underpinning to all the music, with no sense that it is in any way out of place. Listeners interested in ways that some 17th-century composers went beyond scordatura tuning into approaches considerably more outré than are usually associated with this time period will find the works and performances here revelatory. 

     Another new Acis CD connects the music of 400 years ago with the 21st century not through an overlapping approach to the conventions of the time but through a convention of a different sort: the adaptation of works written for older instruments, including ones formerly considered obsolete, for performance on modern ones. This practice is so pervasive as to be thoroughly unexceptional, and it has been going on for centuries as instrumental design and audience tastes have changed. Indeed, it has at times provoked a kind of anti-adaptation movement, as in the return to historically informed performance practices of older music during the last half-century or so, a counterweight to the Victorian-era gigantism that subsumed the modest grandeur of earlier times beneath the weight of massive instrumental and vocal complements. What James Limerick Kerr has done is far more modest and more akin to performing Bach’s harpsichord works on a modern piano: he has selected eight fantasias from Intavolatura di Liuto, Libro 1 of 1599 by Simone Molinaro (c. 1570-1636) and arranged them for hybrid picking guitar. This is a technique rather than an alteration of the instrument: it involves employing a standard pick, held between thumb and index finger, and using the remaining fingers of the hand to pluck the higher strings. The approach significantly widens the guitar’s expressivity and can make it sound like a harp or keyboard producing arpeggios and chords – and this makes it a good choice for solo-lute music such as Molinaro’s. The guitar, however, is not a lute, and the aural difference between Molinaro’s intended soundworld and the one produced by Kerr is significant. It is helpful for modern listeners interested in this adaptation that Kerr has chosen pieces by a less-known composer, who nowadays is more likely to be acknowledged as the source for the first movement of Respighi’s first suite of Ancient Airs and Dances than to be known for his solo-lute originals. Audiences will not likely have an existing aural impression of the Molinaro fantasias with which to compare Kerr’s arrangements, so Kerr’s offerings will have a good chance to stand on their own. They do that quite well: the modern guitar scarcely sounds like a 16th-to-17th-century lute, but Kerr’s adaptations are skillfully done, and he finds in the music a level of warmth and expressiveness that goes beyond what listeners would have expected in Molinaro’s time but proffers pleasantries of its own. Fantasia sesta, for example, is gently emotionally evocative, while Fantasia XV opens strikingly with individual notes that only gradually build toward lyricism and chordal passages. Fantasia quinta is also especially effective in contrasting individual notes with chords. The adaptations and performances here are certainly at a (++++) level, but some elements of the release will make it a (+++) recording for potential listeners. For one thing, it is very short – only 29 minutes. For another, the moderate pacing of these Molinaro fantasias is much the same throughout; the differences among them are subtle and often are matters more of technique – to which Kerr draws attention – than of themes, harmonies and speed. Moderation is the key to all the works here, a function partly of expectations in Molinaro’s time, partly of the inherent qualities of the lute, and presumably partly of Molinaro’s own inclinations when composing these works. The result of all this is a sort of background-music feeling to the CD. It is well-played and undeniably sensitive to the material, and Kerr nicely balances an evocation of the lute with the wider capabilities that he brings to this form of guitar playing. But the overall effect is of a brief foray into a kind of expressive mildness that may be somewhat too rarefied to attract an audience of any considerable size.

No comments:

Post a Comment