The Bombers and the Bombed:
Allied Air War over Europe, 1940-1945. By Richard Overy. Viking. $36.
Perpetual fascination with
the war that ended almost 70 years ago has led historians and scholars to
continue to produce dense, detailed books about nearly every aspect of World
War II. It could be argued that fictional books about the war, such as Catch-22 and Slaughterhouse-Five, tell modern readers, the vast majority of whom
were not born when the war ended, at least as much about the ethos of the war
as extended factual accounts. There is nevertheless a sure place among war
scholars and those who remain fascinated by the conflict for works such as The Bombers and the Bombed, a 562-page
summation and dissection – including 125 pages of notes, bibliography and index
– of the bombing campaign carried out by the Allies against Germany and its
occupied territories in Europe.
This is not a book to be
read casually, because its exhaustive level of detail can be daunting to wade
through, and the style of Richard Overy, a professor of history at the
University of Exeter, favors lengthy sentences and arguments parsed so
carefully that they must often be read and re-read before a reader can be sure
to have absorbed them. Just one typical example: “American officers had in many
cases been drafted into the air force from business and professional
backgrounds, which prepared them for the vocabulary and categories typical of
modern managerial practice. The formal procedure laid down in July 1943
reflected that culture: a conference of key personnel at four in the afternoon
before the operation at which the prospective weather determined the target to
be attacked; target folders checked; fighter escort informed; calculation of
type and weight of bombs and number of aircraft; notification of assigned
combat groups; finally, determination of axis of attack, rendezvous point,
route out, initial point (near the target run-in), altitudes, aiming point,
rally point (just outside the target area), and route back.”
Readers unwilling to put up
with page after page of this precision plodding may want to skim The Bombers and the Bombed to examine
some of the ethical dilemmas posed by the air war in Europe – issues that
continue to resonate today. The notion of “precision bombing” is itself
imprecise, bombs and bombers never having become accurate enough during the war
to avert very high civilian casualties. The extent to which civilians were
deliberately targeted rather than becoming collateral damage is still a matter
of dispute, but the fact is that, one way or the other, the Allied bombers
killed bystanders by the many, many thousands. Some of the instances of extreme
bombing have become well-known, such as the firestorm destruction of Dresden in
the war’s waning days – actually just one of several firestorms that
obliterated large portions of German cities. After the war, Dresden’s
Frauenkirche was deliberately left in ruins, as were prominent churches in
Hamburg and Berlin, as memorials to civilian suffering beneath the bombs – with
the Frauenkirche finally being rebuilt early this century in an attempt, decades
after the war, at reconciliation.
Overy’s book should give 21st-century
readers some idea of just why reconciliation was needed, and why it took so
long to come – if indeed it has. Many of the work’s most interesting and moving
passages, and its most telling photographs, show civil defense efforts in
Germany during and after bombing raids. Overy points out that nine million
Germans eventually were evacuated from bombed cities – an astonishing number.
Photos of the Hamburg firestorm of 1943 and of the circus elephants and
concentration-camp inmates required to help clean up afterwards drive home, with
an emotional punch that Overy’s highly detailed and scholarly text lacks, just
how desperate matters were on the ground because of the Allied bombs.
One view is that the raids
were intended to cause desperation in
order to force the unconditional surrender that eventually was offered in 1945.
Certainly air power was decisive in World War II: it was the nuclear bombs that
fell on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, along with the enormous number that fell in
Europe, that ended the war. The Bombers
and the Bombed is much more than a paean to air power, however. By
including stories about the ground-level effects of the massive European
bombing campaigns alongside detailed information on the campaigns themselves,
by showing (among other things) a propaganda poster in which President
Roosevelt smiles jauntily as bombs destroy Italy, Overy contrasts the “wide
popular endorsement of the bombing campaign” with the realities of what the
cost of the campaign was, both militarily and among civilians on the ground. Certainly
postwar euphoria led to a belief that bombing was the long-sought solution to the
difficulties of pursuing modern war – a belief given the lie in Vietnam. But
the postwar response to the Allied bombing campaign in Europe is beyond the
scope of The Bombers and the Bombed.
What readers who want a great deal of detail about the intricacies of modern
warfare will find here is an extremely carefully researched, well-balanced
portrayal and explanation of a prime component of the Allied victory of 1945 –
and its cost to all involved, both during the war and afterwards.
No comments:
Post a Comment