Tanguero: Music from South America. Christoph Denoth, guitar.
Signum Classics. $17.99.
Music for Saxophone and Harp. Admiral Launch Duo
(Jonathan Hulting-Cohen, saxophone; Jennifer R. Ellis, harp). Albany Records.
$16.99.
The word “tanguero” means “one who sings
or dances the tango,” and although neither Christoph Denoth’s voice nor his
feet may be heard on a new Signum Classics CD, his sense of song and dance
rhythms is everywhere present. Of the 21 tracks on the disc, one-third are by Ástor Piazzolla – scarcely a surprise, since it was he who moved the tango
past the dance hall and into the concert hall. The seven Piazzolla arrangements
here, many with origins in the theater, get their full emotional due in
Denoth’s playing. They include Piazzolla’s own stated favorite, Adios nonino,
whose subtle mood changes are beautifully communicated, along with the
more-urgent Libertango and Verano porteño, the more-inward-looking
Oblivion and Milonga del ángel, as well as Triunfal and Chiquilín de Bachín. The
depth and variety of the Piazzolla works is reflected in Denoth’s choice of
pieces by other composers as well – and not only tangos, since Denoth is
looking for ways in which South American dance forms, plural, intersect with
classical music, which means exploring more widely. Thus, although there is a high-quality
tango here by Carlos Gardel, El día que me quieras, there are also
Venezuelan interpretations and expansions of the waltz in the works by Antonio
Lauro: El Marabino, Valse Venezelano No. 2, and Valse Venezelano No.
3. The saudade makes an appearance as well, in Egberto Gismonti’s Agua y
vinho, and there is even a tango that is not quite a tango, the
tongue-in-cheek Tango en Skaï by Roland Dyens. Denoth,
who is Swiss, shows considerable sensitivity to the ways in which South
American dance forms, broadly defined, explore and interpenetrate European
norms in the classical-music field. There is actually little on the CD that is
new, whether arranged for guitar or written for it: Denoth appears more
interested in presenting a carefully arranged and thoughtful program than in
offering anything truly revelatory. So listeners interested in tango have
likely heard El choclo by Ángel Villoldo, La Cumparsita by Gerardo Motos
Rodriguez, Sueño de barrilete by Eladia Blázquez, Sons de Carrilhões João by Teixeira Guimarães de Pernambuco, Se ela
perguntar by Dilermando Reis, Te vas milonga by Abel Fleury,
Milonga by Ernest Cordero, and Violetas by Julio Sagreras –
or at least some of these. Familiar or unfamiliar, though, all the works share
a folkloric background to which the composers in their own ways have applied
rhythmic changes, traditional variation form, extended harmonies, and other techniques
common to classical music. By bringing these elements to the forefront while
performing the pieces with sensitivity, Denoth offers tango lovers – especially
those of a refined and perhaps somewhat academic bent – a fascinating
exploration of the ways in which simple dance forms have evolved into something
more complex and of greater emotional depth.
Emotional expression is not the primary
reason for being of a fine-sounding new Albany Classics CD featuring the Admiral Launch
Duo. This is a disc for curiosity seekers, strictly for listeners intrigued by
the unusual combination of saxophone and harp and interested in hearing the
ways in which 10 composers of the 20th and 21st centuries
have chosen to explore the instruments. Yet even those listeners will obtain
what they are looking for only in part, because – as often happens in
contemporary music – some of the composers are more concerned with extending
the sonorities and ranges of the two instruments than they are with exploring
them. Given the fact that the repertoire for this combination is quite limited,
one might expect composers to be eager to add to it, but that is so in only
some of the works here, not all. Particularly successful is Romance for Soprano Saxophone and Harp
(1991) by Yusef A. Lateef (1920-2013), whose three movements allow the
saxophone and harp to intermingle with charm, warmth and joyfulness. La Lettre du Jardinier (1912) by Marcel
Tournier (1879-1951), originally for voice and harp, offers an outpouring of feeling
that comes through clearly even without the original words by Henry Bataille.
And parts of the five-movement suite Eolienne
by Ida Gotkovsky (born 1933) – arranged by the composer in1978 for saxophone
and harp after originally being written in 1969 for flute – also lie well on
the instruments and allow them the expressiveness of which they are capable. On
the other hand, Thaumaturgy (2015) by
Patrick O’Malley (born 1969), Amhrán na Cásca
(2014) by Christine Delphine Hedden (born 1990), and Kitchen Dance (2015), also by Hedden, seem mostly interested in
pushing the saxophone and harp to extremes that undermine their natural beauty
– and in the case of Kitchen Dance, which
is essentially an electronic composition, making the acoustic instruments
almost irrelevant. The remaining works here fall somewhere between effective
use of the instruments and their, in effect, deliberate misuse: starshine & moonfall (2014) by
Natalie Moller (born 1990), one of those works whose absence of capital letters
in the title may be intended, like the music itself, to convey a level of
intimacy, but which does so only imperfectly; Whirlwind (2015) by Stephen Rush (born 1958), the longest piece on
the CD (nearly nine minutes), which lacks sufficient breeziness to sustain its
duration; Still Here (2017) by
Angélica Negrón (born 1981), one of those sociopolitical works (in this case
about emotionally abusive relationships) that asks the instruments to convey
more than they are capable of putting across; and the thoroughly look-how-clever-I-am
...nice
box! “Oh So Square” (punctuated exactly that way for no reason
whatsoever), written in 2014 by Jasper Sussman (born 1989) and conveying not
much of anything, which appears to be its intent. The sound possibilities of
saxophone and harp are quite intriguing, and at their best, the works on this
CD show how fascinating the combination can be. Unfortunately, too many of the
pieces seem only to want to show off the composers’ belief in how clever they
are at writing for this instrumental combination. The result is that the sound mixture
in their pieces never comes across as effectively as it does in the few works
here in which the focus is more on performers and audience communication than
on the self-assertion of artful craftiness by the creators of the musical
material.
No comments:
Post a Comment