Max Tilt: Fire the Depths. By
Peter Lerangis. Harper. $17.99.
The Glass Spare. By Lauren
DeStefano. Harper. $17.99.
The parade of novels for
preteens and young teenagers in which skin color and ethnicity are placed
front-and-center despite having nothing to do with plot, character development,
speech patterns or anything else continues to grow. This approach makes sense
in terms of trying to reach out to wider audiences for these books, but it is
unfortunate that little is actually done with the material, which becomes
shorthand for characterization rather than an element of it. Even authors as
experienced as Peter Lerangis and Lauren DeStefano lean unnecessarily and
rather lazily on the “appearance” angle to give information about characters in
their latest series. Lerangis’ Max Tilt
sequence has one of those intriguing but silly, vaguely historical premises
that Lerangis favors: two cousins search for a treasure hidden by their mutual
ancestor, Jules Verne. Max, the 13-year-old title character, has a white mother
and Dominican father, while Alexandra (Alex), his college-age cousin, has an
African-American mother and white father. The thing is, the two cousins think
alike, and that rather than their parentage is what matters. In fact, what is
most interesting about Max is that he has autism spectrum disorder, which
means, first, that he tends to take everything literally (leading to a series
of misunderstandings, some of them humorous); and, second, that he has a
certain degree of synesthesia, which means that to him, emotions have odors
(fear = fish). In real life, most people now bend over backwards to avoid
defining other people by their illnesses, disabilities or other physical
characteristics, but in Max Tilt, it
is Max’s outside-the-norm perception and behavior that make him who he is. Max
is left in Alex’s care (she is taking time off from college to write a novel)
when Max’s parents have to go to the Mayo Clinic so his mother can have medical
tests. Max and Alex soon discover tons of unpaid bills in Max’s home, including
an eviction notice. So they decide to help by selling some of the stuff in
Max’s parents’ attic – where, wonder of wonders, they discover a chest once
owned by Verne. And the chest contains clues that lead to a lost Verne
manuscript that suggests that Verne’s supposedly fictional stories were
actually based on reality. Furthermore, there are indications that there is a treasure
to be found by anyone who can follow Verne’s clues – a potential solution to Max’s
family’s money problems and hopefully to his mother’s health issues as well. Absurdity
piles on absurdity here, mounting higher when Max and Alex encounter the
typical nefarious businessman type who has plenty of money and gadgets and henchmen
and such and who is also after the putative Verne treasure – resulting in an uncomfortable
relationship of teens with bad guy, which in turn leads to a globe-spanning
adventure with the distinct flavor of 20,000
Leagues under the Sea. The puzzles in Max
Tilt are often clever, and so is Alex, who is defined primarily by
creativity (that novel-writing idea) and a certain rebellious streak. Max,
whose synesthesia is his most interesting quality, pairs well with his cousin,
and the “uneasy alliance” theme keeps the plot moving in often-unbelievable but
frequently entertaining ways. Max Tilt:
Fire the Depths is at bottom a fairly standard adventure tale for young
readers, with Lerangis’ typically skilled pacing moving the story along well
and neatly setting up the novel as the first in a multi-book series.
The Glass Spare, intended as the first book of only two, is aimed
at slightly older readers (13 and up rather than 8-12). DeStefano creates a
rather odd setting here: much of the world is standard-issue fantasy, but there
are also steampunk elements such as dirigibles and technological ones such as
data goggles, as well as telephones and other forms of technology. The whole
thing does not hang together particularly well. The racial element here mixes white,
15-year-old central character Wilhelmina (Wil) Heidle, fourth child and only
daughter of the royal family of Arrod and therefore a “spare” in the family
line to the throne, with brown-skinned Loom, banished prince of an enemy
kingdom. The twist in the story, scarcely an unusual one, involves Wil’s
unexpected discovery that she has a limited but potentially significant power.
Specifically, it turns out that under the pressure of an adrenaline rush, her
touch can kill people by turning them into gemstones. Wil’s power emerges
during a moment of self-defense and immediately haunts her. It is destined to
haunt her family, too, including her siblings: heir-to-the-throne Owen, sickly
but gifted alchemist and inventor Gerdie, and cruel and heartless Baren. Wil’s
father is a power-hungry warmonger, and after Wil discovers her deadly ability,
she justifiably fears being put to use to further his ambitions – as has
already happened to Gerdie. Unfortunately, Wil accidentally kills a family
member right in front of her father, and she is immediately banished – soon to
be captured by rebels, including Loom. A romance predictably blossoms between
Loom and Wil, and indeed there is a great deal that is predictable about The Glass Spare, including the cardboard
nature of most characters and the generic reasons they have for their actions. It
is difficult to care very much about any of the people – the authorial
manipulation of their actions and emotions is overly obvious – and the rather
odd world building makes the book less involving than might be expected from a
work that contains so many disparate elements. The underlying themes of good
and evil, science and magic, are conventional ones as well. Perhaps the planned
sequel, which is clearly set up at the end of The Glass Spare, will more effectively tie together some of the
scattered elements found here.
No comments:
Post a Comment