Penguins Love Colors. By
Sarah Aspinall. Blue Sky Press/Scholastic. $17.99.
The Little Elephant Who Wants to
Fall Asleep. By Carl-Johan Forssén
Ehrlin. Illustrated by Sydney Hanson. Crown. $16.99.
The things kids can learn
from books are many and varied, and the ways they can learn them are equally
multifaceted. There are plenty of books about colors for early readers and
pre-readers, but few have the bright intensity of Sarah Aspinall’s Penguins Love Colors. And few have an
equally clever premise: Aspinall sets the book in the black-and-white world of
the South Pole, using six color-loving baby penguins and an appreciative and
highly mess-tolerant penguin mother to show human kids most of the colors of
the rainbow. Aspinall pleasantly carries her black-and-white-vs.-color theme
throughout the book: even the title page has the words “Penguins Love” in black
on a white background and the word “Colors” in the six colors that she will
present. The penguins are subtly distinct from each other on the title page, as
parents may want to show children: each has slightly different head-topping
fur. Within the main part of the story, though, the six are distinguished only
by the different colors of the hats they wear. The penguins’ names reflect
those colors: Tulip’s hat is red, Tiger Lily’s is orange, Dandelion’s is
yellow, Violet’s is purple, Bluebell’s is blue, and Broccoli’s is green. The
little penguins decide to make a surprise for their color-loving mother, who is
the one, after all, who named them. For each color, Aspinall shows a two-page
spread with a big, big splotch of the color next to the penguin that uses it,
and with the name of the color in the
color (“red” is printed in red, “orange” in orange, and so on). The bright,
clear illustrations make the colors abundantly clear, and the different
positions of the penguins painting with them keep the story interesting – as do
the different sorts of messes that the little ones make. By the time the present
for Mama is finished, each penguin is completely
covered in its particular color, but Mama does not care – she just loves the
colors appearing all over the white snow. So the paint-smeared little penguins
are happy, and so is their mother, who takes them off for a bath that shows
their different head-top fur and leaves the tub a six-color mess, after which
all the little ones cuddle up to Mama for a much-needed nap. The little
penguins are so endearing that the huge mess they make seems a small price to
pay for enjoying the story and learning so clearly about six different colors –
but parents should make it clear to their
little ones that, however much they love them, they would not appreciate things getting as messy as they do in Penguins Love Colors.
The little penguins fall
asleep happily and easily after their painting adventure, but bedtime is not
always easy for many children – or parents. That is why Swedish behavioral
scientist Carl-Johan Forssén
Ehrlin self-published a book called The
Rabbit Who Wants to Fall Asleep, which was so successful that he has now
created a similar, professionally published one called The Little Elephant Who Wants to Fall Asleep. Ehrlin’s book is as
quiet, slow-moving and dimly colored (by Sydney Hanson) as Aspinall’s is loud,
fast-paced and bright. And Ehrlin’s work is really an instruction set for
parents and children, disguised as a story – a circumstance that some families
will likely find off-putting. Still, the lesson is worth trying to learn if one
is dealing with a child who has significant problems at bedtime. Parents definitely
need to go through the book before reading (that is, using) it as a sleep aid. Ehrlin
explains that it is “specifically for the time when your child needs to go to
sleep, and therefore I don’t want the book to be too exciting, as it will have
the opposite effect and it will take longer for your child to fall asleep.”
Exciting it certainly is not – and there are specific instructions for parents
on how to read it. Text in bold is to be read emphatically; text in italics
should be read as soothingly as possible; the many times that “[name]” appears,
parents should say the child’s name; and when “[yawn]” is shown in the text,
parents should yawn. There is a very great deal of verbiage in the book, much
more than in most books aimed at young children – but this one is aimed at them
in a different way from others. All that happens in the story is that a little
elephant named Ellen walks through a magical forest to the place where she
likes to sleep, meeting several sleep-inducing creatures along the way: Snoozy
Mole, Snoring Sophie the kind little forest troll, Dozing Daniel the parrot,
and so on. Eventually Ellen reaches her sleeping spot, where her father is
waiting for her, and she falls asleep – as, presumably, does the human child
listening to the story, although Ehrlin structures the tale so that there are
many places where a child may fall asleep, and it is not necessary to read the
story all the way through. The writing style here is curiously stilted –
whether that is because of Ehrlin or because of the translation by Neil Smith
is uncertain. A typical paragraph: “Ellen the Elephant says to you, ‘I think we
should go right and fall asleep twice as
quickly and deeply now, how comforting. That path will also help us to fall
asleep more and more quickly every evening, [name], and sleep well even without
this story. It always works for me.’” Purposely writing a book that is boring,
or at least sleep-inducing, is actually a clever way to try to help children
who simply cannot relax enough to fall asleep. But there is a real question
whether they will sit still long enough for The
Little Elephant Who Wants to Fall Asleep to have its effect. Kids who are
trying to sleep but cannot may benefit from the use of this book as a bedtime
story; ones who are just too full of energy to sleep will not put up with its
repetitiousness and lack of action. Because it is of limited usefulness and is
presented more as a lesson for parents (who in turn make it into a
falling-asleep lesson for children) than as a pleasant, warm bedtime story, the
book gets a (+++) rating: it is essentially a “go to sleep” lecture. It may
very well work under certain circumstances, and is definitely worth trying for
a child who tries and tries and tries to sleep but simply cannot. For most
children, though, there are many more-interesting, comforting, warm and caring
books that will better serve as bedtime tales.
No comments:
Post a Comment