Mahalia Jackson: Walking with
Kings and Queens. By Nina Nolan. Illustrated by John Holyfield.
Amistad/HarperCollins. $17.99.
My Name Is Truth: The Life of
Sojourner Truth. By Ann Turner. Illustrated by James Ransome. Harper.
$17.99.
Harlem Renaissance Party. By
Faith Ringgold. Amistad/HarperCollins. $17.99.
Bronzeville Boys and Girls.
By Gwendolyn Brooks. Illustrated by Faith Ringgold. Amistad/HarperCollins.
$6.99.
It is a shame that
self-segregation by self-identified groups of one kind or another makes it
difficult today for members of other groups to appreciate the accomplishments
of the ones that choose to stand apart. These four books all profile people
whom it would benefit all young readers to know; but the books are deliberately
targeted only at African-American children, presumably to show them
larger-than-life (or at least very interesting) characters of their own color –
but therefore turning the works into specialty items rather than the
more-general-interest ones they deserve to be. This is largely the result of
political correctness run amok, of special-interest groups using silly phrases
such as “people of color” (all people
have color, including albinos) while insisting that similar-sounding phrases
such as “colored people” forever taint those using them. There is genuine
pathos in this, if perhaps not out-and-out tragedy, because it means that
people who are not within the chosen group for which these books were created
are far less likely to benefit from the stories they tell.
And there is plenty of
benefit to be had here – for children of any color. Mahalia Jackson: Walking with Kings and Queens and My Name Is Truth: The Life of Sojourner
Truth are both brief, surface-level biographies of women whose
contributions to music and the abolitionist movement, respectively, are
deservedly valued at very high levels. Both books tell their stories from a
highly personal perspective, although Nina Nolan’s is narrated in the third
person and Ann Turner’s in the first. The Mahalia Jackson story features John
Holyfield illustrations in which all the prominent characters are subtly
rounded and Mahalia herself constantly stands out from whatever background she
is portrayed against. It briefly traces Jackson’s life from her birth in
poverty in New Orleans in 1911 to her singing at Martin Luther King Jr.’s March
on Washington in 1963 (King’s widow spoke at Jackson’s own funeral in 1972, but
the book omits Jackson’s later life). The focuses throughout the book are
music; Jackson’s remarkable, untrained voice; and the ways in which Jackson’s
chosen focus on gospel lifted the lives of African-Americans. The only
individualized white person in the book, a singing teacher, is shown denigrating
Jackson – a shame, since her music could and did reach beyond those of her own
color. Similarly, Turner’s story of Sojourner Truth (c. 1797-1883) features
attractive, involving James Ransome illustrations of Truth and her family, with
pictures of whites being done as caricatures that make such people look
clownlike when they do not appear overtly evil. Truth’s story is a remarkable
and uplifting one for people of any faith or no faith: although motivated by
religion, what she preached was rights and equality, concepts that resonate
with Americans of any color. The author’s note at the end of this book is a big
help in understanding more about Truth’s life: the book itself is rather spare,
providing more emotional impact than factual material. Readers who spend some
time with the back-of-the-book material will appreciate the biography more
fully than those who read only the story.
Faith Ringgold pulls
together African-Americans of many times and places and has them all show up in
Harlem during the New Negro Movement, which was later called the Harlem
Renaissance. An imaginary little boy named Lonnie goes to Harlem with his Uncle
Bates to meet the many famous people there, encountering Marcus Garvey, W.E.B.
Du Bois, Paul Robeson, Josephine Baker, Zora Neale Hurston, Langston Hughes and
many other celebrities. Lonnie is simply a device to draw readers of roughly
his age to a story into which Ringgold not only places well-known people but
also introduces specific locations: Harlem itself, the Harlem Opera House, the
Savoy Ballroom, the offices of The Crisis
magazine, the Schomburg Library, and so on. Ringgold’s five back-of-the-book
pages about the characters and places in Harlem
Renaissance are a virtual necessity for young readers trying to make sense
of the book, which is densely packed with people and events. There is no
particular story here – the book is basically a recitation of various people’s
names and various locations – although Ringgold tries near the end to provide
uplifting messages to her target readers by having Lonnie say, “I am so proud
to be black” and by having him describe a dream in which “I was the proudest,
littlest giant of the Harlem Renaissance.”
Ringgold’s contribution as
illustrator of Bronzeville Boys and Girls
is actually more involving than is her writing-plus-illustration in Harlem Renaissance. The reason is that
the Bronzeville children, created in 1956 in poetry by Gwendolyn Brooks, seem
real and alive and genuine, even though they are entirely fictional – unlike the
stylized “important people” of Harlem
Renaissance, who seem more like unidimensional cardboard characters even
though they really lived. Bronzeville
Boys and Girls is set in a section of Chicago, but could take place just
about anywhere urban. All the characters here are black, but their
personalities are such that children of any color can relate to them if only
they have a reason to pick up the book (which dates to 2007 and is now
available in paperback) in the first place. For instance, a poem featuring a
boy named “De Koven” is an appealing eight-liner: “You are a dancy little
thing,/ You are a rascal, star!/ You seem to be so near to me,/ And yet you are
so far./ If I could get you in my hands/ You’d never get away./ I’d keep you
with me always./ You’d shine both night and day.” And four lines are enough for
“Robert, Who Is Often a Stranger to Himself,” which goes: “Do you ever look in
the looking-glass/ And see a stranger there?/ A child you know and do not
know,/ Wearing what you wear?” And “Michael Is Afraid of the Storm” offers
emotions that any child who, like Michael, is eight years old, will understand,
beginning: “Lightning is angry in the night./ Thunder spanks our house./ Rain
is hating our old elm—/ It punishes the boughs.” Many of the names of children
here are or were more common in African-American households than in other homes:
Tawanda, Keziah, Eldora, Beulah, Mirthine. But aside from that, Bronzeville Boys and Girls is simply a
story of urban children – not famous people, not people of a specific
orientation or skin color, but simply children trying to cope with and
understand life as they live it. This is a book that can reach out widely and
effectively, and it does – but only if and when families beyond those obviously
targeted by the book take the time to look for and explore it.
No comments:
Post a Comment