Annie and Helen. By Deborah
Hopkinson. Illustrated by Raul Colón.
Schwartz & Wade. $17.99.
Harlem’s Little Blackbird: The
Story of Florence Mills. By Renée
Watson. Pictures by Christian Robinson. Random House. $17.99.
Alex the Parrot: No Ordinary
Bird. By Stephanie Spinner. Illustrated by Meilo So. Knopf. $17.99.
Daddy Christmas & Hanukkah
Mama. By Selina Alko. Knopf. $16.99.
Room for the Baby. By
Michelle Edwards. Illustrated by Jana Christy. Random House. $17.99.
Outcasts United: The Story of a
Refugee Soccer Team That Changed a Town. By Warren St. John. Delacorte
Press. $16.99.
Even in the few dozen
pages of a picture book for ages 4-8, it is possible for an author to
communicate a great deal of engagement, pathos and real-world information, all
of which Deborah Hopkinson provides in Annie
and Helen. This is the latest of many books about the relationship between
the young Helen Keller and her teacher, Annie Sullivan, and it is quite an
extraordinary introduction to an even more extraordinary story. Hopkinson keeps
the words simple but affecting: “Helen was like a small, wild bird, throwing
herself against the bars of a dark and silent cage.” Hopkinson intersperses her narration with
excerpts from Sullivan’s own writings, and Raul Colón’s sensitive illustrations effectively imagine the facial
expressions and body language of teacher, student and the few other characters
in the book. The difficulties Sullivan encountered in teaching Helen are
clearly explained: “She didn’t understand that each motion [made in spelling
out words in sign language] was a letter, that letters made up words, and that
words could be names for things.” But after the famous breakthrough when Helen
understands the word “water,” Helen learns remarkably quickly, and Hopkinson
explains some of Helen’s further education and the delight she took in
learning: a Colón illustration
showing Helen in four poses, leaping into the air and landing again on the
ground, is tremendously expressive of the joy of discovery. The book ends when
Helen, during a trip, is able for the first time to write a letter to her
mother – and the letter, from 1887, is on the story’s final page. A tale that
remains touching, heartwarming and uplifting no matter how often it is told,
the story of Helen Keller is beautifully presented in Annie and Helen – in a way that hopefully will inspire young
readers to learn more about it from other sources.
Florence Mills is as
little-known to most people as Helen Keller is well-known. A short-lived singer and stage performer (1895-1927,
although the book gives her birth year as 1896), whose voice was never recorded
and whose performances were never filmed, Mills was famous in her own time, an
era of deep-set segregation. Mills was
black – Duke Ellington composed the song Black
Beauty as a tribute to her – and she was a trailblazer in many ways: the
first black woman photographed for a full spread in Vanity Fair, she was offered a leading role in the Ziegfeld Follies
and would have been the famous show’s first black star if she had not turned
Flo Ziegfeld down. A very poor girl,
daughter of former slaves, Mills used her tremendous talent first to pull
herself up in the world and then to give others of her race a chance to perform
as well. The best thing about Harlem’s Little Blackbird is that the
book reaches out to children of all races: although African-Americans can be
justifiably proud of Mills, it scarcely matters (except historically) that
Mills was black and that Renée
Watson and Christian Robinson are as well.
This is not to minimize the discrimination and racial troubles that
Mills had to overcome – but this is, at heart (and it is full of heart), a book
about a young person with talent learning to harness and develop her abilities,
overcome the difficulties of her external circumstances, and succeed, to a very
great extent, on her own terms. It is an
uplifting tale that does not try to hammer home politically correct messages
about the evils of racism and discrimination – instead, it tells the story of a
little girl who made it big in a life cut tragically short by tuberculosis (a
fact not mentioned in the book). More surprising than the omission of the
illness that caused Mills’ death is the fact that the book does not give her
nickname. It was not “blackbird” – the book’s title comes from a line in one of
Mills’ songs. No, what Florence Mills
was called was “the Queen of Happiness.”
There is a real bird
at the center of a more-recent real-life story in Stephanie Spinner’s Alex the Parrot. Alex was a year-old African grey parrot
bought at a pet shop in 1977 by graduate student Irene Pepperberg, who then
spent 30 years demonstrating the remarkable intelligence of African greys –
something taken for granted now but deemed out of the question just a few years
ago, when “most people thought that animals were just barely intelligent” and
scientists believed that learning correlated strictly with brain size, which
would mean that African greys’ walnut-size brains could not be good for much
beyond management of basic bodily functions.
Pepperberg spent years teaching Alex and finding ingenious ways to
determine that he really did understand what he was talking about – for
instance, he invented the word “banerry” to describe an apple (banana +
cherry). Alex, shown by Meilo So engaged in many forms of learning, had real
personality and was no more patient with repetitive testing than are young
children, so he rebelled by sometimes ignoring his trainers or deliberately
giving the wrong answer. Spinner’s book
is about progress in science and about the way entrenched ideas sometimes need
a single champion, or just a few, to question them. Spinner introduces Roger
Fouts, who taught Washoe the chimp sign language, and Francine Patterson, who
did the same for Koko the gorilla – Fouts and Patterson were among the few
scientists who knew that animals other than humans could speak and understand
words. But Pepperberg’s work with the bossy, impatient Alex was something
entirely different, and her work with another African grey, Griffin, after
Alex’s death in 2007, has extended our knowledge of animal communication
further. The subject of Alex the Parrot
is an unusual one in a book for young readers; just as Alex was no ordinary
bird, this is no ordinary book.
Daddy Christmas & Hanukkah Mama is more straightforward and
more to be expected at this time of year, but Selina Alko’s (+++) tale still
has its share of real-world pleasures. It is, as the title makes obvious, the
story of a religiously mixed family: “Our tree is crowned with one shiny star./
And we light eight candles for Hanukkah.”
The whole book consists of ways in which the family mixes Jewish and
Christian winter traditions, sometimes in quite charming ways: “Mama scatters
golden gelt under the tree./ Daddy hooks candy canes on menorah branches.” The unnamed girl who narrates the story helps
with the decorating, the singing “about Maccabees and the manger,” the cooking,
the gift-giving and the storytelling: “Uncle Zachary recalls the miracle of the
oil./ Aunt Faith tells about the animals in the manger.” Everything is pleasant, warm and cooperative,
even during post-holiday cleanup and a look ahead at the new year and “all the
other holidays following/ Hanukkah and Christmas.” There is not, though, a single forthright
mention of the religious underpinnings of the two winter holidays (of which the
Christian one is far more important to members of that faith than the Jewish
one is to Jews; the primary Jewish holidays occur at other times of the year).
The book is really for families comparable to the one invented by Alko, who
already know the differing traditions and will enjoy reading about inventive
ways to mix celebrations together.
Room for the Baby, another (+++) story with a strong Jewish flavor,
also uses an invented family to present real-life circumstances. Here the subject is the soon-to-come new baby
(announced by Mom “one fine spring morning, as we buttered our Passover
matzos”), and the need to clear enough space for a crib in the family’s sewing
room. The book is also about recycling,
because what is all over the room is old material, such as worn-out sheets,
that Mom has been meaning to work on but has never quite gotten to remake. Now,
spurred by her pregnancy, she makes “dozens of soft diapers for the baby” and
then some more for a neighbor’s coming granddaughter; then she makes clothing,
and “that autumn on Rosh Hashanah…Mom had stacks of tiny sleepers and onesies
and little shirts ready for the baby.” And
sure enough, neighbors admire the clothing and want some for their own
families, and Mom obliges – she is clearly an excellent and very fast-working
seamstress. There is no particular
reason for the family to be Jewish in Michelle Edwards’ and Jana Christy’s
book, but Jewish holidays are used to mark the progress of the seasons and the
pregnancy, and the new baby, a girl, is born on the third night of Hanukkah. And in a final pleasant twist to a very
pleasant story, after the boy narrator gives away a last batch of unneeded
items to make a little more space in the sewing room, those items return in
modified form as baby gifts made by all the neighbors for whom Mom had made
clothing. It is a gentle and entirely
suitable ending for a sweet book.
Real-world stories for
young readers are of course not limited to picture books. Outcasts
United is a (+++) adaptation by Warren St. John of his adult book, Outcasts
United: An
American Town, a Refugee Team, and One Woman's Quest to Make a Difference.
The subtitle has been changed for younger readers, ages 8-12, and the story has
been shortened and simplified, but it remains essentially the same: the Fugees,
a youth soccer team made up of refugees from around the world, have a dramatic
season in the town of Clarkston, Georgia, under the inspirational leadership of
their tough coach, Luma Mufleh. The team members are from various war-torn
countries; Mufleh herself is Jordanian, although educated in the United States.
Although the story is essentially true, it follows the fictional arc of many,
many sports-as-bonding stories: team members learn how to behave on and off the
field, find out how to start making new lives for themselves in their adopted
country, and learn to get along with each other and their coach; and everyone
matures and learns something about himself or herself. There are debates and disputes – about hair
cutting, about bonding with young people, teammates or not, from the same
country, vs. bonding with the team as a whole.
There is slow progress with learning English and understanding what the
coach wants; there are comical or almost-comical moments, such as the Under
Thirteen team doing laps only when in Luma’s line of sight, but otherwise
walking and chatting while she cannot see them; and there are, of course, the
games, some of which inevitably go better than others. And when one goes well,
“Her players, some of them still strangers to each other, were high-fiving and
shouting joyfully at the sky as they ran toward her on the bench.” The whole book is both heartwarming and
obvious from start to finish; despite the many problems and all the heart-tugging,
or perhaps because of them, it reads almost like a fairy tale come true – one
with sports at its center.
No comments:
Post a Comment