January 14, 2021

(+++) AGAINST TYPECASTING

When Sharks Attack with Kindness. By Andrés J. Colmenares. Andrews McMeel. $12.99.

     Sharks represent so much to so many people. In the main, they are fearsome creatures, top predators, unstoppable marine killers, to be avoided if possible, killed if necessary, and feared at all times. These are the sharks of Jaws and its innumerable sequels and spinoffs. At other times, they are fascinating creatures about which much remains unknown, cartilaginous fish dating back 400 million years, a thousand species of which many remain virtually unstudied. These are the sharks of scientific inquiry. At still other times, in a far more lighthearted way, they can be comic-strip characters with strong personalities that bear zero resemblance to anything in the real world but that make for all sorts of amusement as the cartoon sharks interact with many other underwater creatures that also bear zero resemblance to anything real. These are the sharks of Jim Toomey’s long-running, ecologically aware Sherman’s Lagoon – and, in a very different way, of Andrés J. Colmenares’ Wawawiwa Comics, from which the new collection, When Sharks Attack with Kindness, is drawn.

     Talk about playing against type: Colmenares here creates an entire book (indeed, actually an entire strip) in which sharks are sweet, kind, loving, helpful and friendly – and surrounded by lots of other sweet, kind, loving, helpful and friendly marine creatures, all sporting rather realistic-looking bodies with not-realistic-at-all smiling faces. Although a great white shark is central to the strip and the book – Toomey’s central character is also a great white – Colmenares also peoples his world (and “peoples” is the correct term for characters as anthropomorphic as these) with a hammerhead, a whale shark, and critters ranging from octopus and jellyfish to penguin, polar bear, seagull, pelican, clam (yes, a smiling clam), and even a “sea human” who explains at the outset that he is “not supposed to be here.” Well, not if “here” is underwater, where the strip takes place, but the little boy fits neatly if “here” is a realm where kindness rules and all interactions are modest, sweet and non-threatening.

     This all sounds a little too good to be true, and indeed there is something a bit treacly about When Sharks Attack with Kindness, whose message is essentially the same on every page. However, Colmenares’ sincerity and nicely honed drawing style keep the book interesting, and even though the amusement here is mild, the book is amusing – and that is worth something. In one strip, the great white shark is seen in typical tooth-showing terrifying pose, but turns out only to be waiting for his morning cup of coffee. In another, the shark urges a catfish not to eat a slice of pizza, but the catfish eats it anyway, ending up pizza-slice-shaped (essentially a triangle), and the shark says, “You’ve changed species” – to which the reply is, “Totally worth it.”

     A lot of the strips in When Sharks Attack with Kindness do lay on the supportive and positive elements a bit too thickly and obviously. For instance, there is the strip in which a young shark complains that he is bad at drawing because he can only make a bunch of wavy lines, so the main great white shark swims in with a compliment: “Wow, buddy! You drew an ocean!” For another example, the great white takes his friend, a pilot fish, to see “my most valuable treasure,” and they are seen swimming toward a treasure chest piled high with gold. Then the shark indicates what is next to the treasure chest and says, “It’s the rock where we met!” A little of this niceness goes a long way; a lot of it goes, well, a bit too far, even during a time period when we can all use as much niceness as we can possibly get.

     Colmenares is so darn well-meaning, though, that it seems churlish to complain that he is somewhat too sweet – given all the things in life and the world that are a great deal too bitter. So When Sharks Attack with Kindness works as a counterbalance to a lot of the mean-spiritedness that the book’s readers surely deal with on a regular basis. Seen that way, as an antidote for nastiness and negativity, Colmenares’ pleasantries are a great deal more welcome than they might otherwise be. The electric eel that helpfully recharges the great white’s cell phone, the birthday candles that turn out to be happy angler fish, the flounder whose “good side” is the one with both his eyes visible – these become characters showing readers a kinder and gentler way to view things than is usually available in the not-undersea world. And from time to time, Colmenares comes up with notions that are cute and funny enough to produce a genuine chuckle, as when the big (adult) great white advises the small (young) great white to “try to reach for the stars,” and the young shark responds to the clichéd advice by picking up several starfish and saying, “Done! Now what?” When Sharks Attack with Kindness may not be great cartooning or great thinking, but these days, any heaping helping of kindness is more than worth its weight in – well, in pearls, like the one Colmenares shows inside a clam, even though pearls actually grow in oysters. Shhhh…don’t say anything about that. Be kind.

(+++) THE USES OF PASTICHES

The Little Tin Box: A Collection of Childhood Memories. The 5 Browns. Steinway & Sons. $17.99.

Vivaldi: Argippo. Emőke Baráth and Marie Lys, sopranos; Delphine Galou and Marianna Pizzolato, contraltos; Luigi De Donato, bass; Europa Galante conducted by Fabio Biondi. Naïve. $20.99 (2 CDs).

     Thematically related but somewhat thrown-together musical programs can be a lot of fun to listen to, provided that the audience finds their overall themes congenial. The Little Tin Box is a highly personal presentation by the 5 Browns (Desirae, Deondra, Gregory, Melody and Ryan) of music remembered from childhood and, in the case of these top-quality pianists, likely performed then: each of the five started studying piano at the age of three. The memories are sanitized, with the Steinway & Sons release calling them “a reclaiming of [childhood’s] sweetness and beauty” involving “finding greater meaning in the light by having survived the dark.” The three female siblings were sexually abused by their father for nearly a decade, so their assertion of positive childhood memories through this music has something that is more than a touch plaintive about it. However, the music itself has little in it that is bittersweet: most of it is familiar encore-like material, either written for solo piano and arranged for the 5 Browns or created for orchestra and heard here in piano arrangements. It is not necessary to know the “through darkness to light” undercurrent of the CD in order to enjoy it – indeed, it may help not to know it, since the music is mostly plain and simple and is played expertly and without apparent chiaroscuro. The 5 Browns are heard individually as well as in two-piano and five-piano arrangements. The works include Smetana’s Vltava (Die Moldau); Grieg’s Anitra’s Dance from Peer Gynt; Mozart’s Rondo alla Turca from the K. 331 solo sonata and Allegro con spirito from the two-piano sonata K. 448; Dr. Gradus ad Parnassum from Debussy’s Children’s Corner; Emile Waldteufel’s Skater’s Waltz; the first movement of Beethoven’s Symphony No. 5; The Current, a work written and played by Ryan Brown; Couperin’s Les Barricades Mystérieuses from the second book of pièces de clavecin; five of the 13 Kinderszenen by Schumann; and a delightful (but, in context, somewhat odd) improvisation by Desirae’s six-year-old daughter, Poppy Luch, called I Wish I Could Turn Back into a Kid. The pleasant pastiche feeling of the recording makes specific comments on its contents somewhat irrelevant. The flowing-water material in the Smetana may not sound particularly convincing when heard on five pianos; the very slow start to Rondo alla Turca and the jazzy improvisations within it are scarcely Mozartean (although the movement from the two-piano sonata is first-rate); Beethoven’s Fifth is delivered with high drama and contrasts nicely with the comparative calm of The Current immediately afterwards; Schumann’s Bittendes Kind (“Pleading Child”) takes on unintended darkness in this context, and the simple beauty of Träumerei (“Dreaming”) comes with more seriousness than the music itself holds; and it is hard to know how to respond to the concluding I Wish I Could Turn Back into a Kid – Poppy’s voice, introducing it, is full of enthusiasm; the music itself is scarcely significant except in context; and the underlying sentiment, again in context, is a trifle puzzling. The title The Little Tin Box speaks to the concept of opening a tinkly little music box and hearing whatever melodies may emerge from it – a sweet notion, and one that fits this mishmash of a musical mixture well enough. The disc, for those who can hear it strictly on the surface level with which the music is delivered, is quite enjoyable. For those who, knowing something of the family history of the 5 Browns, cannot hear it that way, the CD is jarring in ways that neither the composers nor the performers could have intended.

     Pastiche was actually a musical form of its own for a time: it was a common and respected approach to opera in Vivaldi’s era, and a form that Vivaldi himself used. To create pasticcio, an impresario/composer would assemble material from multiple composers, write some connective-tissue music, work from a libretto that could itself have elements of hodgepodge about it, and have the resulting assemblage performed by itinerant opera companies. This is how Vivaldi’s pasticcio opera Argippo (1730) was offered in productions in Vienna and Prague. The original version of the opera is lost, which makes the work fit rather uneasily into Naïve’s long-running and always excellent Vivaldi Edition, which is designed as a set of presentations of Vivaldi music held at the National University Library of Turin. But awkward or not, the Vivaldi Edition has now made a version of Argippo available as the 64th entry in the two-decade-long series – the numbering itself being a trifle odd, since this two-CD set comes out later than the 65th release, Il Tamerlano, which itself has elements of pasticcio through its inclusion of arias by other composers: Geminiano Giacomelli, Johann Adolf Hasse and Riccardo Broschi. Argippo as heard in this recording is a critical edition prepared as recently as 2019 and including in its 19 arias music by Giovanni Battista Pescetti, Johann Adolph Hasse, Nicola Porpora, and others. Bernardo Ticci, who reconstructed the opera from manuscript material, has produced about as coherent a work as can be expected in a Vivaldi-era pasticcio or, for that matter, in some of Vivaldi’s own operas – which is to say, it is not very coherent at all. The libretto by Domenico Lalli overflows with the same elements heard in many operas of the time by Vivaldi and others: political and personal intrigues, family rivalries and conflicts, lovers’ passion and misunderstandings, and outsize emotions that overflow and are by and large over-the-top. This is the stuff of which opera, especially Italian opera, would consist for hundreds of years, so the improbability of Argippo is largely irrelevant to the quality of its music – much of which is very high-quality indeed. Among the high points are the always-reliable Delphine Galou singing an aria di furore in Act I, Se lento ancora il fulmine, and Marie Lys warmly presenting an Act III love tune, Vado a morir per te. Fabio Biondi directs the singers and the ensemble Europa Galante with skill and a determination to keep the music plowing bravely ahead even when the plot thickens or thins for little reason, as it does repeatedly. The result is a recording that will be of considerable interest to Vivaldi fans and to listeners interested in some of the byways of operatic history, even though Argippo is not, in and of itself, particularly noteworthy. It does, however, demonstrate that contemporaries of Vivaldi were as capable as he was of producing effective operatic material – and that Vivaldi could function with considerable skill as a musical assembler and theatrical producer, not just as a composer.

January 07, 2021

(++++) AID FOR THE ACCIDENTAL TEACHER

1st Grade at Home: Reading and Math Skills—A Parent’s Guide with Lessons & Activities to Support Your Child’s Learning. By the Staff of The Princeton Review. Princeton Review/PenguinRandomHouse. $12.99.

     Never let it be said that even the most destabilizing events can fully smother the American entrepreneurial spirit. There is innovation to be channeled out there even in the midst of a pandemic that has upended the work and home lives of millions upon millions of people. And that definitely includes children, who have had to relearn the basics of getting an education – and parents, who have had to relearn, or learn for the first time, the basics of providing an education.

     It is difficult to say on whom these dislocations and depredations have been harder. Back in the 1960s, mathematician and musical satirist Tom Lehrer wrote and sang a paean to what was then called “new math,” empathizing with parents trying to help their kids do homework without ever have studied the subject themselves: “Hooray for new math, new math: It won't do you a bit of good to review math. It's so simple, so very simple, that only a child can do it!” Extend that sentiment to just about every subject taught in school today and you have a fair approximation of how parents, abruptly thrust into the role of teachers, have every right to feel.

     To the rescue come the entrepreneurial types at The Princeton Review, an organization best known for its very thick, data-driven college guides. Why not use the skills honed in producing those guides to create educational books that parents can use to pull themselves and their children through, say, first grade? And lo and behold, there arises 1st Grade at Home: Reading and Math Skills (plus similar entries for second, third and fourth grades). This is not “new math” in the 1960s sense but new math – and reading – in the 21st-century-pandemic sense. It is intended to transform parents into carefully guided substitute teachers who can take their kids, step by step, through the same kind of learning that children would be getting in classrooms if it were not for lockdowns, lockouts, cutbacks, illness, fear of illness – well, the sorry litany goes on, but the feeling of being deluged by impossible demands where education is concerned does not have to persist for families using these books.

     1st Grade at Home tackles the two subjects of its title in a careful, well-organized fashion. The reading section begins with sound identification and pronunciation, the math section with simple counting exercises. The reading section eventually builds to story creation and interpretation, including visualization through drawing of the primary elements in a story. The math section eventually leads to charting and graphing activities. Along the way, the book takes parents step by small step through specific ways to present material, using items that will be easily found in most homes: pencil, pen, crayons, glue, note cards, paper, mini elbow macaroni – mini elbow macaroni? Yes: in addition to the expected teaching materials that parents likely remember from their own schooling, 1st Grade at Home makes lessons interesting by including such elements as old photos, popsicle sticks, modeling clay, pennies, board games, pretzel sticks, a muffin pan, and more. “Interesting” may fall short of “fascinating,” though, and little comments throughout the book – made to look like taped notes – remind parents about what it is like to be a first-grader. “First graders tire easily,” says one cautionary reminder. “Don’t try to do all of these activities at once.” Another says, “First graders can be moody. Sometimes they are not in the mood to do anything. If you find your child acting moody, don’t force him or her to do something. …You don’t want your child to associate learning activities with negative feelings.”

     There are direct warnings for parents, too, in the form of sections labeled “Watch Out!” There are a lot of those: one two-page spread early in the book contains three of them, and only a single section that is not called “Watch Out!” Parents may be forgiven for feeling somewhat overburdened by all the things to watch out for, in addition to the more-positive material covered in sections called “Checking In” and “What to Know.” Still, the book’s guidance is measured and its topics well-arranged – and the suggested timings for specific activities help provide a sense of pacing as well as structure. Some of the activities are very specific indeed, in sections called “Jump Right In!” These are not unlike school handouts: “Choose the word that completes the compound word,” or “Read aloud all the numbers in the picture below. …Then, color [using the color to which each number corresponds].”

     It does help to remember that teaching is as much an art as a science, and the creation of books that help people teach is an art, too. Guidance can go only so far. To cite one example among many, 1st Grade at Home includes a poem about watching a witch cooking something, and asks what the observing character’s face might look like – giving three choices, with one child looking alarmed, one smiling, one looking serious and worried. The answer given as “correct” is the look of alarm – but good teachers know that it is a child’s explanation of an answer that often matters more than the response itself. Any of the faces can be “correct” if the reason for the choice is explained by the child – and the more inventive the explanation, the better (whereas giving the “right” answer may simply mean giving the teacher what he or she wants, an endemic issue in education).

     Well, a book can do only so much, and 1st Grade at Home does a great deal. It informs, guides, assists, orients and, yes, educates parents as well as children. The math section even gets clearly into the base-10 system, place value and grouping tens and ones – topics that are at the heart of Tom Lehrer’s half-century-old concerns for parents, who in Lehrer’s song are told to do calculations in base eight. Now that is something not covered in 1st Grade at Home, and parents can and should be glad that it is not. They also can and should be glad that, most of the time, well-qualified teachers rather than overwhelmed and overextended parents are in charge of teaching reading and math. One thing all parents will definitely learn from 1st Grade at Home is that teachers certainly, emphatically, definitely deserve to be appreciated more and paid better. As a tribute to the combined reading/math curriculum in this book, determination of the mathematical percentage increase that professional teachers should receive is left as an exercise for the reader.

(++++) BEETHOVEN AND BEYOND

Beethoven: Piano Trios, Op. 1, Nos. 1-3; Op. 70, Nos. 1 (“Ghost”) and 2; Op. 97 (“Archduke”). Trio Sōra (Pauline Chenais, piano; Clémence de Forceville, violin; Angèle Legasa, cello). Naïve. $26.99 (3 CDs).

Beethoven: Symphony No. 3; Mahler: Symphony No. 10—Adagio. Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by JoAnn Falletta. Beau Fleuve. $15.

Florent Schmitt: La Tragédie de Salomé; Musique sur l’eau; Oriane et le Prince d’Amour—Suite; Légende. Susan Platts, mezzo-soprano; Nikki Chooi, violin; Women’s Choir of Buffalo and Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by JoAnn Falletta. Naxos. $11.99.

     Given Beethoven’s seminal position in the Romantic era, it is all too easy to forget that he really straddled Classical and Romantic times and formed his reputation based on his handling and modification of musical forms perfected by such Classical masters as Mozart and Haydn – to both of whom Beethoven owed a greater debt than he tended to acknowledge. Beethoven’s piano trios make his provenance particularly clear as they progress from his first published works (1795) through the well-known “Archduke” trio (1811). Trio Sōra offers compelling readings of six of the trios in a new three-CD Naïve release. There are other Beethoven piano trios, for a total count of 12, including WoO 38, written before the Op. 1 trios, and the “Gassenhauer” (Op. 11 of 1797), originally for piano, clarinet and cello but often performed in its alternative version for piano, violin and cello. But the fact that the Trio Sōra recording makes no attempt to be comprehensive does not diminish the quality of the project or the effectiveness with which the performers show Beethoven’s development from his earlier period into his middle one. The Op. 1 trios are very clearly derived from the Mozart/Haydn era, but they already show Beethoven’s distinctive voice, and Trio Sōra takes full advantage of this. The opening of the very first trio is an ascending arpeggio known in Classical times as a “Mannheim rocket,” and Beethoven’s use of it affirms his ties to the Mozart/Haydn era while giving Trio Sōra an immediate opportunity to display the joie de vivre and tendency toward faster tempos that are evident throughout these performances. The group takes its oddly spelled name from a Native American word meaning “a bird that sings as it takes flight,” and seems determined to live up to that designation from the very first notes here. A single-word description of the Trio Sōra performances could be “high-spirited,” but at the same time, Pauline Chenais, Clémence de Forceville and Angèle Legasa do not hesitate to provide intensity when it is called for, as in Op. 1, No. 3, which is in the portentous-for-Beethoven key of C minor. Indeed, because Trio Sōra uses modern instruments, including a full-sounding Steinway piano, there is ample warmth and depth when called for – sometimes even a bit more than is called for, although the trios’ slow movements are generally handled without undue sentimentality. Still, the players seem particularly happy to be engaged in much of the lighter material in Op. 1, such as the finale of the second, G major trio. When they move to the Op. 70 trios, their clarity of attack and articulation serves them particularly well, and their willingness to explore the emotional depth of the Largo assai ed espressivo of Op. 70, No. 1 – the movement that gave this work its “Ghost” nickname – stands them in good stead. The players’ handling of the dynamic range of the later trios is especially impressive, with focused attention on the pianissimo sections as well as the louder ones. The fine blending heard in Op. 70, No. 2, a work unjustifiably neglected between the “Ghost” and “Archduke,” is particularly impressive and makes a strong case for the music. The “Archduke” itself, however, is a bit problematic here. The second-movement Scherzo is halting rather than flowing, with the players pausing after each four-bar phrase at the opening just long enough to impede the forward motion. And the finale’s opening is odd: the Trio Sōra members start the movement hesitantly and only gradually build up to the designated Allegro moderato main tempo. They never lose their sense of ensemble, however, and the concluding Presto material is impressively handled. Still, this “Archduke” is a bit less convincing than the other works offered here. On the whole, however, Trio Sōra proves itself a very high-quality ensemble, skilled at interpreting these Beethoven trios and absolutely first-rate in the give-and-take that the music requires.

     The on-the-cusp-of-Romanticism elements of Beethoven’s music are the primary reason-for-being of a new Beau Fleuve recording featuring the composer’s “Eroica” symphony played by the Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra under JoAnn Falletta. It is not really possible to pinpoint a specific work or specific date and say, “the Romantic Era began here,” but Falletta’s choice of Beethoven’s Third is certainly an arguable point of demarcation if one feels the need to choose one. The notion underlying the recording, which is dubbed “The Romantic Age,” is that Beethoven ushered in that emotion-packed era in music and Mahler escorted it out through the first movement of his Symphony No. 10, with which the Beethoven is here paired. The choice of the Mahler work from 1910 is less defensible than that of the Beethoven – why not Schoenberg’s String Quartet No. 2 (1908) or Pierrot Lunaire (1912), or (to move matters much later) Rachmaninoff’s Symphonic Dances (1940)? Falletta did not offer the two works on this CD under this disc’s title as a concert pairing: the Beethoven was recorded live in May 2019 and the Mahler in February 2020. So the juxtaposition seems more expedient than anything else. Still, there are interesting contrasts between the pieces, and the Buffalo Philharmonic plays them both with strength and intensity – and very fine string sound, which is especially crucial in the Mahler. Falletta starts the “Eroica” less than decisively in its first two chords, but quickly rights matters with a well-paced first movement (a bit on the fast side) whose propulsiveness is convincing. The omission of the exposition repeat is, however, unconscionable and indefensible. The second movement is stately rather than emphatically funereal, sad rather than tragic – and lightened to a greater-than-usual extent by its woodwind elements and some of the string figurations. This makes the “Eroica” less definitively Romantic than its inclusion on this disc would indicate, but it fits the movement well and effectively sets up the final two movements, which can sometimes seem tacked-on after the very expansive first two. The light and speedy opening of the third movement works well in Falletta’s interpretation, and the strings play enthusiastically. The horn entry in the trio slows matters down a bit, but the horns’ very fine hunting-call sound is most welcome. The third movement ends speedily and moves attacca into a finale that is notable for its bounce and rhythmic vitality, and that concludes with genuine panache. All in all, this is a well-integrated, well-thought-through performance that successfully presents the symphony as a whole instead of placing the majority of emphasis on the first two movements. It would be interesting to hear whether Falletta would handle Mahler’s Tenth in an analogous way: although not completely orchestrated, the work was essentially finished at the composer’s death and has been offered as a complete symphony in many versions. This makes it much less reasonable to extract its first movement, one of the two left 100% complete (the third movement being the other), and to play it as a standalone work, as Falletta chooses to do. The performance itself is fine: the straining against tonality of the music comes through as clearly as does its sense of constant yearning, and the eerie effects that Mahler coaxes from the orchestra are played with understanding. Mahler habitually treated his large orchestras as extended chamber groups, requiring sections, parts of sections, or individual players to emerge from the whole ensemble and then fall back into it. Falletta and the Buffalo musicians handle this aspect of the music quite well. The decision to play only this single Mahler movement is a questionable one, and the label “The Romantic Era” for this disc is more a matter of marketing than musicianship, but the performances here are worthy, and there is insight to be had in hearing these very different composers’ works in close proximity.

     Beethoven’s influence extended to and past Mahler, but the Germanic style that he epitomized was not the only prominent one in the Romantic era and afterwards. Florent Schmitt (1870-1958) represents a different approach, a French style along the lines of Fauré and Massenet, with both of whom Schmitt studied. It is interesting to contrast the balletic elements of Beethoven’s Third, whose finale derives from a theme the composer used earlier in The Creatures of Prometheus, with the ballet-originating sounds in the Schmitt works that are heard on a Falletta/Buffalo Philharmonic release for Naxos. Schmitt was primarily an impressionistic composer, as is evident in all four pieces on this disc. La Tragédie de Salomé, a two-part symphonic poem that dates to 1910 and started out as a ballet, unusually includes, in the second part, a mezzo-soprano voice. Less intense, impassioned and frenetic than Richard Strauss’ one-act opera of five years earlier, Schmitt’s work opts more for Oriental flavor and an overall feeling of the exotic than for Strauss’ mixture of seductiveness and murderous intent. Schmitt’s music is very well performed by the orchestra, and as on the Beethoven/Mahler disc, the ensemble’s fine string section does a first-rate job of tone painting, while Susan Platts handles the vocal elements with aplomb. Platts is also heard in the 1898 voice-and-orchestra version of the brief Musique sur l’eau, which lacks the sweep and atmosphere of Debussy’s La mer (1903-05) but has a pleasant flow of its own. Schmitt’s music tends to pale by comparison with that of better-known composers, but it stands up well when heard on its own, without preconceptions. On that basis, the suite from Oriane et le Prince d’Amour is finely colored, nicely orchestrated, and offers effective contrasts among its sections. It is also clearly late-Romantic in sound despite dating to 1934-37 – further evidence, if any were needed, that the door to the Romantic era did not close after Mahler’s Tenth. The Schmitt CD concludes with a work from 1918, the violin-and-orchestra version of Légende, a piece originally featuring solo saxophone and perhaps more interesting in that guise. Nikki Chooi plays it well and with feeling, but it has a rather ordinary and undistinguished sound to it. Falletta is a strong advocate for Schmitt’s music, and certainly Schmitt deserves better than the obscurity into which he has fallen. But the reality is that although he was a skilled craftsman, he was not, on the basis of the works heard on this (+++) CD, especially innovative: most of these pieces sound like somewhat warmed-over versions of music by composers with an equal sense of style but a greater portion of creativity and inventiveness.