Charles-Valentin
Alkan: Complete Organ Works, Volume 1—11 Grand Préludes and Transcription of
Handel’s Messiah; Messiah Recitative and Arioso; Petits préludes sur les huit
gammes du plainchant; Impromptu on Luther’s “Un Fort Rempart Est Notre Dieu.” Joseph Nolan, organ. Signum Classics. $19.99.
Rameau:
Le Berger fidèle; Handel: Mi palpita il cor; Albinoni: Sonata in C for Oboe and
Continuo; Thomas-Louis Bourgeois: Diane et Endimion; D. Scarlatti: Sonata in D
minor; Louis-Antoine Lefebvre: Le Lever de l’Aurore. Hannah De Priest, soprano; Les Délices (Debra Nagy,
baroque oboe and director; Shelby Yamin and Kako Boga, violins; Rebecca
Landell, cello and viola da gamba; Mark Edwards, harpsichord). AVIE. $19.99.
Poptimism. Vesna Duo (Liana Pailodze Harron, piano; Ksenija
Komljenović, percussion). UNCSA Media. $7.99.
Like his contemporary
and musical if not geographical compatriot, Franz Liszt, Charles-Valentin Alkan
was renowned for his prodigious, seemingly almost supernatural pianistic
virtuosity and for composing music whose complexity defied the capabilities of
pretty much every performer except himself. Also like Liszt, Alkan was a keyboard virtuoso, not a pianist alone,
performing extensively not only on piano but also on organ, and, yet again like
Liszt, composing a significant body of work for that instrument. Indeed, Alkan
in one sense went beyond Liszt, for he was also strongly involved in and
acclaimed for his playing on and composing for the pedal piano, a now-obsolete
instrument equipped with an organ-like pedalboard on which the performer plays
lower notes, much as is done on the organ. Alkan’s piano music has been moving
into mainstream performance by modern virtuosi for several decades now, but his
works for organ and/or pedal piano (sometimes designated by him as being for
one instrument or the other) remain almost wholly unknown. So the start of a
planned sequence of Alkan’s complete organ music on the Signum Classics label,
featuring Joseph Nolan, is a genuine rarity and would be at least a fascinating
curiosity if the music were straightforward. But nothing in Alkan is ordinary,
and the first Nolan volume clearly showcases compositions of considerable
musical interest, exceptional (and unsurprising) difficulty, and a
preoccupation with the religious themes that recur throughout Alkan’s oeuvre (the fact that his 30-year
labor-of-love translation of the entire Bible from its original languages into
French appears to have been permanently lost is a real tragedy, one of several
involving Alkan). All the works performed on this first disc by Nolan – all
handled by him with skill and what appears to be intuitive understanding of
Alkan’s style – have religious tie-ins. The 11
Grand Préludes and Transcription of Handel’s Messiah are expansive and
contemplative pieces, not simple transcriptions of music from the oratorio
(notwithstanding the title of this work). Conflating and inflating Handel’s
original material, Alkan turns elements of Messiah
into grand studies of harmony and counterpoint that pull additional meaning and
emotion from a work already packed with both. The fourth piece, marked Moderatamente, is especially intense and
dramatic; the ninth and longest, Langsam,
is wonderfully expressive and emotive; and the final two, Scherzando and Lento,
provide exceptionally well-thought-out contrast between some lighter (but still
foundationally serious) material and some that is conclusively thoughtful and
contemplative. Alkan’s transcription of Thy
rebuke hath broken His heart and Behold,
and see, given the title Messiah
Recitative and Arioso, is separate from the 11 Grand Préludes but clearly partakes of their sensibilities,
further showing the extent to which Alkan – who was Jewish and said he believed
that only a Jew could adequately translate the New Testament – absorbed and
understood Handel’s music and its underpinnings. Interestingly, all the Handel
items were designated by Alkan as being written for organ, pedal piano, or
piano three hands, with a second pianist’s hand needed to fill in some of the
material. Not so the Petits préludes sur
les huit gammes du plainchant, however. The sonorous complexity of the
Handel-based material contrasts interestingly with this spare, for-manuals-only
set of études that demonstrate the eight modes of Gregorian plainchant. These
show Alkan’s music in its most stripped-down form and, in the context of this
CD, provide a welcome respite from the density and harmonic complexity of the
pieces based on Messiah. Nolan caps
this remarkable first exploration of Alkan’s organ music with Alkan’s
intriguing, extended Impromptu on
Luther’s “Un Fort Rempart Est Notre Dieu,” in which the famous Ein feste Burg ist unser Gott is
displayed in a combination of variation and sonata form, becoming both a meditation
on the well-known music and a thoroughgoing exploration of its depth of feeling
and potential for polyphonic development. An exceptional work on all levels,
this Impromptu builds to what seems
to be a towering climax sufficient to shake the ecclesiastical rafters – until
Alkan, never one to produce what is expected, eventually has the music fade
away into quiet chords whose effect lingers long after their actual notes fade.
All the music here sounds splendid under Nolan’s thoughtful virtuosity and through
the richness of the Stahlhuth-Jann Organ of St. Martin’s Church in Dudelange,
Luxembourg – an instrument with a checkered history whose 21st-century
restoration has resulted in an aural setting that fits Alkan well even though
the organ dates to after the composer’s lifetime. This CD most definitely whets
the appetite for additional Alkan organ recordings that are still to come.
Audiences with an appetite for some less-often-explored Baroque music sequenced
in a somewhat quirky manner and performed with panache will enjoy a (+++) AVIE
recording featuring soprano Hannah De Priest and the five-member ensemble Les
Délices. The group’s name means “the delights,” and certainly there are a
number of those in this mixture of secular cantatas and instrumental works by
composers both well-known and unfamiliar. The disc opens with Rameau’s Le Berger fidèle, a sequence of three
recitative-and-aria pairs whose intended impressions Rameau makes abundantly
clear, labeling the first aria plaintif,
the second gai, and the third vif et gracieux. De Priest captures the
rather modest emotional compass of the music fetchingly, not overdoing the feelings
but presenting them in a kind of statuesque form, reflecting their existence
within the idealized, much-mythologized realm of Arcady of which many Baroque
composers were fond (indeed, the CD as a whole bears the title “Arcadian
Dreams”). The French expressiveness of Rameau contrasts with the Italianate
approach of Handel in the second offering on the disc, Mi palpita il cor. This too is a set of three recitatives and
arias, but Rameau’s near-equivalent length of arias gives way in Handel to
significant differences both in duration and in emotional intensity. Indeed,
the less-than-one-minute first aria, Agitata
è l’alma mia, requires some vocal gymnastics that almost derail De Priest.
She is far more comfortable in the extended, delicate second aria, Ho tanti affanni in petto, and the
pleasant third, S’un dì m’adora,
although this concluding item does bring her a touch of strain in its
acrobatics. The cantatas are followed by a work that serves as an instrumental
palate cleanser, an Albinoni oboe concerto, and here the delights of Les
Délices come through clearly and cleanly in more than a supporting role:
rhythms, balance and harmonies are handled with elegance, and the ensemble’s
sound is simply lovely. The CD continues with Diane et Endimion by Thomas-Louis Bourgeois (1676-1750), who offers
two rather than three paired recitatives and arias. The second aria, Une frayeur mortelle, with its minor-key
intensity, is the most impressive element here, and is suitably emotive (if
scarcely frightening) within the imagined Arcadian context. A slow-paced D
minor harpsichord sonata by Domenico Scarlatti is offered next, showcasing both
the composer’s always-adept writing for the instrument and harpsichordist Mark
Edwards’ skill with the work’s moody expressiveness. The CD then concludes with
Le Lever de l’Aurore by Louis-Antoine
Lefebvre (c. 1700-1763), in which dawn’s rising is conflated with the emergence
of love. Delicate both in its verbal elements and its instrumental
accompaniment, this work is pleasantly inconsequential, fitting well into its
time period and the theme of this recording without being particularly
distinctive. Still, it is very well-performed, as are all the pieces on this
disc, which seems designed for a limited and rather fey audience that will delight
in its modest pleasures.
The pleasures are equally modest, if quite different, on a short (29-minute)
and very up-to-date recording bearing the rather oblique title Poptimism and featuring piano and
percussion (or, more accurately, piano and other
percussion). The six tracks here are reinterpretations and expansions of
various pop-and-rock-music songs with which listeners need to be highly familiar for this (+++) UNCSA Media disc to have any suitable impact. Modern
popular music is so strongly tied to specific performers (so-called “covers”
notwithstanding) that the CD will be of greatest interest only to an audience
enamored of all six of the underlying works. However, there is something to be
said for the impressive melding and contrasting of Liana Pailodze Harron’s
pianism with the precise and knowing percussion work of Ksenija Komljenović: to
some extent, the disc is enjoyable simply for the skill with which its material
is presented. It opens with riffs on Rihanna’s Diamonds and then proceeds to With
You by Dean Lewis, Sting’s Shape of
My Heart, Hozier’s Take Me to Church,
Soundgarden’s Black Hole Sun, and
finally Run the World (Girls) by
Beyoncé. This is scarcely great music, indeed not being intended to outlast the
various performers’ careers except perhaps coincidentally if others eventually
pick up some of it. But the Vesna Duo’s arrangements do have some high points: With You is especially winning in its
deliberate absorption of piano-as-percussion-instrument into the wider
percussive complement, and the rhythmic bounce of Take Me to Church is engaging. There is something charming here in
what is essentially an old-fashioned jam session – it seems somehow suitable
that the front cover of the CD case is filled by a picture of a now virtually
obsolete audiocassette. Despite the comparatively limited interest of the
material underlying this two-person presentation, the disc does show that there
is considerable talent for musical performance at the University of North
Carolina School of the Arts.