Beethoven:
Piano Concertos Nos. 3 and 4—transcriptions for piano and string quintet. Hanna Shybayeva, piano; Utrecht String Quartet (Eeva
Koskinen and Katherine Routley, violins; Mikhail Zemtsov, viola; Sebastian
Koloski, cello); Luis Cabrera, double bass. Naxos. $11.99.
Beethoven:
Piano Concerto No. 1; Symphony No. 2—transcriptions for piano and string
quintet (Concerto) and for string trio (Symphony). Hanna Shybayeva, piano; Animato String Quartet (Floor
Le Coultre and Tim Brackman, violins; Elisa Karen Tavenier, viola; Pieter de
Koe, cello); Bas Vliegenthart, double bass. Naxos. $11.99.
Beethoven:
Piano Concertos Nos. 2 and 5—transcriptions for piano and string quintet. Hanna Shybayeva, piano; Animato String Quartet (Inga
VÃ¥ga Gaustad and Tim Brackman, violins; Elisa Karen
Tavenier, viola; Pieter de Koe, cello); Bas Vliegenthart, double bass. Naxos.
$13.99.
This is a fascinating foray into Beethoven’s piano concertos and also,
truth be told, a rather weird one. The musical moving force here, and one of
the few consistencies in the three Naxos CDs, is pianist Hanna Shybayeva, who is
interested in exploring some lesser-known nooks and crannies of the musical
past. These transcriptions certainly qualify. They result primarily from a
collaboration between Sigmund Lebert (1821-1884), a well-thought-of pianist and
pedagogue, and composer Vinzenz Lachner (1811-1893) – whose brother Ignaz
(1807-1895) is remembered for chamber arrangements of a number of Mozart’s
piano concertos. Those arrangements, and the ones of Beethoven heard on these
discs, are very much of their mid-to-late-19th-century time: music
lovers wanted to hear great works, recordings did not exist, and full-scale
performances were infrequent and often inconveniently located – but the piano
was developing rapidly, becoming increasingly popular in many homes, and
private performances by string players (families and friends) were
well-established (much of Schubert’s music was written for just such
get-togethers). These circumstances paved the way for accurate, if simplified,
versions of works such as Beethoven’s piano concertos – versions that could
also be used as study scores by aspiring pianists.
The Lebert/V. Lachner concerto transcriptions were created in this
environment, but have had virtually no existence outside it: these recordings
are their first ones. As musical tastes changed, full-scale performances became
more widely accessible, and audiences came to know works in their original
orchestrations, transcriptions such as these fell by the wayside. And that is a
bit of a shame, as these well-played and well-paced performances show, because
while the transcriptions are certainly pale versions of the original concertos,
they possess a level of clarity and lightness that makes them worthwhile to
hear on their own and that also shows elements of the concertos’ structure quite
clearly and to very good effect. A guidepost for all this is the transcription
of Beethoven’s Symphony No. 2 included on the disc containing Piano Concerto
No. 1. The symphony transcription was made by Beethoven himself, and for the
highly limited instrumental complement of piano trio. The challenges of doing
this are obvious, yet Beethoven clearly found the piano-trio instrumentation
adequate (if not ideal) for this symphony, despite the work’s seriousness and
comparatively large scale (well beyond that of No. 1 although not close to that
of No. 3, the “Eroica”). Hearing Shybayeva and members of the Animato Quartet
play the symphony as a trio is a genuinely refreshing experience: certainly
Beethoven knew precisely how he wanted the symphony to communicate, exactly
which musical lines he wanted emphasized, and how he could assign the
non-string portions of the score to a piano trio. Obviously this version does
not hold the proverbial candle to the orchestral one in terms of scope,
fullness of sound, or use of orchestral sections. But it is fascinating to hear
the symphony in this guise, and to know, thanks to this skeletal-but-elegant
version of the work, just how Beethoven himself saw the crucial and
less-crucial elements of the score.
The pleasures are analogous but different in the Lebert/V. Lachner
arrangements, created decades after Beethoven’s death. Although designed for
student or family performance, the concertos as heard here are not minimized in
complexity or compromised in style: the transcribers retain the piano part
(which is expanded in some places to incorporate some of the material
originally written for orchestra), and the orchestral material is sensitively
apportioned among the five string instruments, with the inclusion of double bass
giving the music more heft than it would otherwise have.
Because the transcriptions were designed for in-home or student use, the
specific performers are less important than might otherwise be the case. But
the performer element is a part of the oddity of this generally admirable set
of discs. The musicians are all based or trained in the Netherlands and are all
more than equal to their parts. But the actual sound of the CDs lacks
consistency, not because of recording technology but because of inherent
differences in the way chamber groups play together and the way their
particular instruments interact. And the release sequence of the three CDs is
itself hard to fathom. The first disc includes the third and fourth concertos,
with Shybayeva accompanied by the Utrecht String Quartet. The second CD has the
first concerto plus Beethoven’s trio arrangement of Symphony No. 2, and here
Shybayeva plays with the Animato String Quartet. The third CD includes Piano
Concertos No. 2 (actually the first to be written) and No. 5 (the last one
created); here the quartet has the same name as on the second disc but a
different complement of players. There is thus a certain feeling of hodgepodge
about this whole project, which is a shame.
Turning to the discs’ booklets for explanation does not help, and in
fact confuses matters further. The three 16-page booklets are arranged
differently, give different amounts of attention to the music vs. the
performers, are differently laid out, and are inconsistent (and even
inaccurate) in some particulars: for example, the first two refer to “the
famous Cotta edition of Ludwig van Beethoven’s piano concertos,” while the
third uses the same language but says “piano sonatas.” And this is not a matter
of mistranslation, although the translation from German is inelegant at best,
since the same translator is responsible for all the English versions of the
notes.
It is unfortunate that these three discs, taken together, produce an overall feeling of sloppiness or simply lack of caring in the production of the music, because the music itself is definitely worthy of being heard, even at a time when performances of the original versions of the concertos and Symphony No. 2 are ubiquitous and readily available (and a time when at-home amateur chamber-music gatherings are extremely rare). The Lebert/V. Lachner concerto transcriptions are a part of music history, perhaps little more than a footnote in it, but they are interesting in their own right as well as in the way they make it possible to hear Beethoven’s piano concertos with, as it were, a different set of ears.
No comments:
Post a Comment