Packs: Strength in Numbers. By Hannah Salyer. Houghton
Mifflin Harcourt. $17.99.
Helga’s Dowry: A Troll Love Story. By Tomie dePaola. Houghton
Mifflin Harcourt. $7.99.
There is little doubt that in some
circumstances there is greater strength in a group than in individuals. The
ancient Romans knew this well – hence their focus on the fasces, a bundle of sticks (sometimes containing an ax with its
blade visible) that had been used since Etruscan times to show the power of
being bound together rather than being as weak as an individual wooden rod
would be. But there is such a thing as taking the concept too far, which is why
the much later word fascism –
directly derived from the ancient notion – has less-than-admirable
connotations. Still, for many of the animal groupings explored by Hannah Salyer
in Packs, being bound together is
crucial to survival. Salyer makes her brief considerations of animal packs
entertaining as well as informative both through her art and through two
aspects of her narrative: giving the formal name for each specific collection
of animals, and creating a fanciful overview of what each group does together.
Thus, she explains how some ants head underground – where they are called,
collectively, a nest – and gather green leaves to be used to grow food for the
colony: “Together, we harvest!” And wildebeest, which move in groups as large
as a million individuals in a “herd [that] is called an implausibility,” roam the Serengeti plains: “Together, we travel!”
Salyer anthropomorphizes some animal groups to make a point, as when thousands
of flamingos, “known as a flamboyance,”
eat together and sleep together and find mates together: “Together, we dance!” The
strength-in-numbers approach is frequently used by tiny animals that are
individually weak, such as coral, and by prey animals that need to protect
themselves against predators, such as zebras. Salyer stretches the groupings a
bit by showing a pride of lions (“Together, we nurture!”) and numerous
crocodiles basking in the sun: lions are actually social only to a limited
degree, and crocodiles are not group animals at all, usually coming together
only when a bask of them (“bask” being their collective noun, although it is
one that Salyer does not provide)
happens to want to, well, bask in the same warm area. Inevitably, Salyer ends
the book with a city scene showing a large group of people, in the
now-obligatory forms of racial, ethnic and sexual diversity (e.g., men walking hand-in-hand), and the
statement that “we are better” as a grouping of people (which, in fact, might
be called “a diversity of humans,” although it isn’t). Indeed, Salyer lays on
the lessons a bit too thickly at the back of the book, using the final pages to
discuss ways in which “animals in this book are under threat from things like
climate change, poaching, or habitat loss.” That alters both the topic and the
tone of Packs rather jarringly, but
it does not really interfere with the well-presented basic information about
animal groupings – and can be skipped if one is so inclined. Salyer’s
end-of-book page giving the exact names of the creatures in the book, on the
other hand, should not be skipped by any young reader intrigued by the
illustrations. That page gives, for example, seven different names for the
various corals shown in Salyer’s single picture. There is plenty to enjoy in Packs, and plenty of material that can
be followed up elsewhere, perhaps starting with the six “Further Reading”
examples that Salyer helpfully supplies.
The binding-together element of conformity
can certainly be taken too far when it comes to human beings, as the fasces-to-fascism example indicates. It
can also be taken too far when it comes to trolls, as Tomie dePaola shows in Helga’s Dowry, a delightful 1977 book
now available in a new paperback edition. It seems that all female trolls exist
under a pronouncement from “One-Eyed Odin,” to the effect that “all unmarried
Troll Maidens must wander the earth forever.” But troll maidens cannot marry
unless they have a suitable dowry. And that is Helga’s problem: although
Handsome Lars wants to marry her, she has no dowry at all. So Handsome Lars
goes to Rich Sven for advice – and is promptly advised to marry Rich Sven’s
daughter, Plain Inge. Oops. Well, Helga may be a dutiful member of the troll
grouping, but she is also an individual, and she is not willing to be jilted
just because of group customs – so she tucks her tail out of sight, loads her
troll cart with sundries, and goes “hopping down the mountain into the Land of
People.” Helga is clever enough to know when to go against the group, especially when the group is lazy: at a farm, she
finds a washhouse with no smoke coming out of the chimney and lots of people
just lolling about – and offers to get all the laundry cleaned by sundown in
exchange for 35 cows, with the proviso that if she cannot deliver on time, she
gets paid nothing at all. The greedy farmwife who is in charge of doing laundry
but is not doing it can scarcely resist that deal – but by sundown, thanks to
“troll powder in the water” and “troll wax on the iron,” Helga delivers a
gigantic pile of beautifully cleaned and folded laundry and heads home with her
35 cows. And the next day she heads back to “the People’s Marketplace” to get
something more for her dowry: gold. A bit of “juvenescent cream” containing
troll magic helps old people look young again, and soon enough, the people are
happy and Helga has all the gold she needs. Now all she lacks is a meadow – the
last dowry requirement – and she knows how to get it: by cutting down a
mountainside full of trees. But that part of her plan is foiled by none other
than Plain Inge, who turns herself into a tree and prevents Helga from doing
what she wishes – and there ensues a wonderfully drawn and very funny battle
between Tree-Inge and Boulder-Helga. Yes, Helga turns herself into a boulder
and repeatedly rolls down the mountain to try to turn Inge “into kindling
wood.” But Inge dodges again and again, although Helga cleverly eventually gets
the better of her – and then decides not
to marry Handsome Lars, because “I want to be loved for who I am, not for what
I’ve got!” And there is the moral of the story – and a finely fashioned comeuppance
for Handsome Lars, who has to marry Plain Inge after all, while Helga ends up
with a much better match with a troll
who loves her for what she is and has “no need of riches,” for what turns out
to be a very good reason. Helga’s Dowry
is a delightfully told fable, in which dePaola’s storytelling skill and
immediately recognizable art combine to produce a story about the value – and
limitations – of being a member of a group and doing just what the group
expects.
No comments:
Post a Comment