Belches, Burps, and Farts—Oh My!
By Artie Bennett. Illustrations by Pranas T. Naujokaitis. Blue Apple. $17.99.
Buried Sunlight: How Fossil Fuels
Have Changed the Earth. By Molly Bang & Penny Chisholm. Illustrated by Molly
Bang. Blue Sky Press/Scholastic. $18.99.
I’m Brave! By Kate & Jim
McMullan. Balzer+Bray/HarperCollins. $16.99.
Hmm. Yes, there certainly
are different ways of providing factual information to young readers. Very different ways. Artie Bennett’s
involves tackling bodily functions that are not usually discussed, much less
written about, in polite society, and doing so in such an amusing way that
readers will not know whether to be fascinated or grossed out. Or both at the
same time. Actually, the response depends on the reader, and perhaps on the
reader’s age: adults may be horrified at Bennett books such as The Butt Book and Poopendous, but the kids for whom the rhyming text and abundant
illustrations are intended will more likely be, if not charmed, at least
amused. Oh – and informed, too, since Bennett does get the science (and
anatomy) right. And that brings us to Belches,
Burps, and Farts—Oh My! With inside covers adorned (if that’s the right
word) with Pranas T. Naujokaitis illustrations of kids, babies, snakes,
giraffes, dogs, cats and other creatures emitting gas, with a copyright page on
which a baby’s farts turn into boilerplate information on the book’s
publication, this is a book that never takes itself seriously – but does take its subject matter seriously.
That is a curious combination, and one that works exceptionally well. Even
parents who find the whole topic uncomfortable will have to admit that Bennett
has dug up some fascinating facts: we cannot burp while on our backs; belching during
a meal in China is a compliment, not an insult; jellyfish, sponges and anemones
cannot fart – while the dubious distinction of champion farter goes to the
termite; humans average 14 farts per day; and so forth. More-mundane
information is here, too, in Bennett’s well-structured rhymes: “Animals that
chew their cud/ Pass a massive gaseous flood!” Naujokaitis offers pages ranging
from one showing a boy belching the alphabet in class to one diagramming the
intestinal process that leads to gas expulsion, complete with smiling and
tooting bacteria. The pictures are so exaggerated that they make it difficult
to dislike a topic that simply doesn’t find its way into kids’ books – or
doesn’t usually show up, anyway.
Bennett has a way with words that neatly complements Naujokaitis’ with pictures.
For example, on one page, the words are, “The more you belch,/ the less you’ll
fart./ You could even keep a chart!” The picture shows a boy and girl studying
and, yes, charting the various emissions of a baby. The back of the book offers
two pages of “Fart-tastic Facts & Burp-tacular Bits” that add some
additional science to the narrative, such as “flatus” being the medical term
for farting and “eructation” being the official word for belching, and what
happens when someone burps in space (the lack of gravity usually means some
food comes up as well). Funny, factual and unafraid to tackle topics usually
untouched, Bennett and Naujokaitis produce…err, emit...err, expel…err, offer an offbeat winner of a book in Belches, Burps, and Farts—Oh My!
Molly Bang and Penny
Chisholm tackle a much more conventional topic in a much more conventional way
in Buried Sunlight: How Fossil Fuels Have
Changed the Earth. The presentation here is more along the lines of what is
typical in nonfiction picture books – although having the sun itself as
narrator is a clever touch (and one also used in three previous Sunlight books). Buried Sunlight tackles complex scientific subjects in clear, if
necessarily simplified, form, explaining how photosynthesis works and what “the
cycle of life” is (with Bang’s pictorial representation of the cycle being
particularly attractive and clearly illustrative). The slow transition of Earth
from a planet without oxygen to one with an oxygen-rich atmosphere is explained,
and the way that change relates to the eventual formation of fossil fuels is
presented clearly – including an explanation of why such fuels are, in a sense,
“buried sunlight.” Bang and Chisholm then explain how carbon dioxide gets into
the atmosphere and what it means when “burning fossil fuels and burning your
forests puts more CO2 into Earth’s [atmospheric] blanket every
year.” They explain climate change, but also note that “Earth has changed a LOT
over the billions of years since it was born” – the issue now being not change
itself but the pace of change, which
is “VERY VERY VERY VERY fast.” The book ends with the sun asking whether humans
will “risk the changes” of continuing to use fossil fuels or “work together to
use my ancient sunlight more slowly.” The question is reasonable, whatever
one’s attitude toward climate change may be, and the extensive back-of-book
notes (six pages of comparatively small type, with only a few small
illustrations) can be excellent discussion points for families or classrooms.
The book’s perspective is an intriguing one: “Since the 19th
century, human civilization has been run on ancient sunlight stored in fossil
fuels.” And the authors state directly that “there are things we left out, or
greatly oversimplified, in writing this book.” Buried Sunlight: How Fossil Fuels Have Changed the Earth is
nevertheless a surprisingly comprehensive overview of a complex and difficult
subject, presented in easy-to-follow text with very engaging illustrations. The
one omission that parents or teachers will have to bring up on their own – and
it is a serious one that is not discussed even at the end of the book – is that
of Earth’s population. All the technology and good will in the world that may
be devoted to limiting fossil-fuel use and finding alternative energy sources
cannot possibly cope with the enormous and continuing increase in the number of
humans on the planet. Of course, that is more of a Malthusian book than an
energy-centric one, but the population reality is the “elephant in the room”
when energy use and conservation are discussed – an elephant that is overlooked
here, as in so many other books on the same subject, whether for children or
adults.
Fact-based books need not be
as funny as Bennett’s or as serious as Buried
Sunlight – they can fall somewhere in between, as in the case of I’m Brave! The title does not make it
clear what the book is about: fire engines. But the smiling, rather
self-important-looking engine on the cover points clearly enough to the topic.
Just as the sun narrates Buried Sunlight,
the engine itself is the narrator of Kate and Jim McMullan’s book. This is an
engine with an attitude and a pronounced accent, proclaiming that he carries “a
whole lotta, WHOLE LOTTA HOSE” and has a water cannon “sproutin’ from my HEAD!”
Oh – and he makes it clear that he is “GOOD LOOKIN’, that’s what.” There is serious
commitment behind that on-the-verge-of-bragging way of talking, though, and the
engine gives young readers an interesting guide to firefighting tools –
including not only familiar items such crowbars and drills but also
“duck-billed lock breakers, rabbit-tool door forcers,” and “Halligan tools.”
Kids will actually have an issue with the tool lists, and for that matter, so
will parents, since the McMullans do not provide a key showing which tool is
which – the engine simply asks, “Can you match ’em?” The rest of the book is
clear enough, though, as an alarm comes in and the engine gets down to
business, using blinkers, flashers and light bar to race through traffic and,
at the fire, sets about ordering chocks, hydrant wrench, twin connector, pump
and other equipment to get going – the engine itself issuing commands and
dispatching the tools, there being no human firefighters seen in the book. There
is good, solid information in I’m Brave!
And there is enough that is amusing in the book’s presentation to make the
facts easy to understand and absorb – all in all, a potentially dour subject
handled with a fine combination of the serious and the lighthearted.
No comments:
Post a Comment