Hafliði Hallgrímsson: Klee Sketches, Op. 32, Books
One and Two; Offerto (in memoriam Karl Kvaran), Op. 13. Peter Sheppard Skærved,
violin. Métier. $17.99.
Bach: Cello Suites Nos. 1, 2 and 4, arranged for
bass clarinet. Joshua Ranz, bass clarinet. Navona. $14.99.
Schumann: Symphonic Etudes, Op. 13; Clara Schumann:
Piano Sonata in G Minor. Inna Faliks, piano. MSR Classics. $14.95.
Ensueños de Cuba (Daydreams of Cuba). Elena Casanova, piano. MSR
Classics. $14.95.
Since Icelandic composer Hafliði
Hallgrímsson (born 1941) is also a fine cellist, it would be reasonable to
expect string-solo music by him to focus on the cello. But a new Métier CD with
Peter Sheppard Skærved instead features the solo violin – and shows Hallgrímsson
to be quite adept in writing for it. There are two multi-movement suites here
called Klee Sketches, both dedicated
to Skærved and both showing fine command
of the violin’s solo capabilities – along with some rather esoteric tone-painting
and equally abstruse wit and humor. Hallgrímsson’s musical sound here is
approachable and often genuinely interesting, although some familiarity with
the art of Paul Klee (1879-1940) is certainly needed to get the full flavor of
movements with titles such as “Klee Experimenting with a New Scale,” “Do Not
Neglect Your Pizzicato Herr Klee,” “Klee Sounds Out an Etching He Is
Contemplating,” and “Klee Entertaining Kandinsky” – that movement referring to
Wassily Kandinsky (1866-1944), who, along with Klee, was one of the artistic
group known as Die Blaue Vier (“The
Blue Four”). Hallgrímsson clearly draws inspiration from Klee’s very personal
stylistic mixture of cubism, surrealism and expressionism, and seems to have no
trouble producing 15 movements (between the two solo-violin suites) with
references (admittedly sometimes oblique) to Klee – who, it is worth noting,
himself created some 9,000 works, leaving plenty for Hallgrímsson to be
inspired by. The two Klee suites are interestingly complemented by the earlier
(1991) Offerto (in memoriam Karl Kvaran),
which Hallgrímsson created in memory of his friend, an artist who lived from
1924 to 1989. Unlike Klee, Kvaran is not internationally known, but
interestingly, Hallgrímsson’s four-movement Kvaran memorial suite speaks more
directly and universally than do his more-rarefied Klee Sketches. The movement titles in Offerto are not entirely reflective of the music’s sound, but do
show the contemplative nature of the material: “Written in Sand,” “Lines
without Words,” “The Flight of Time,” and “Almost a Hymn.” Skærved plays all
the material on this disc knowingly, idiomatically and expressively,
emphasizing now the music’s dissonant and overtly “modern” elements, now its
more-lyrical and emotional ones. Hallgrímsson’s music is something of an
acquired taste, but this release shows it to be interesting and involving
enough to be worthwhile for more people to acquire.
The cello is also central to, yet absent
from, a new Navona disc featuring Joshua Ranz on bass clarinet. Ranz, perhaps
quixotically, has arranged three of Bach’s suites for solo cello for his own
instrument, and the results are – well, odd. It has often been said that Bach’s
music has such perfection and purity that it can be played with equal effect on
any instrument, and Ranz’s arrangements and performances certainly put that
assertion to the test. The clarinet itself is an instrument of wide range, with
considerable warmth and depth in its low chalumeau
register, but the bass clarinet is a darker and expressively more-limited
instrument. It comes across quite well in the Sarabande of the first suite, for example, but somewhat more
awkwardly in the two Minuets that
follow, as well as in the concluding Gigue,
which Ranz tries hard to make jaunty but which actually sounds a bit
off-balance. The disc stays in the major key after the first, G major suite –
No. 4 is in E-flat – and here the opening Prelude
is particularly impressively played, although again it is the fourth-movement Sarabande that fits the tonal and
emotive qualities of the bass clarinet best. Suite No. 2, in D minor, concludes
the CD and is particularly intriguing for the way its moods complement the
capabilities of the bass clarinet – which Ranz plays especially well here,
notably in the very deepest notes, which have substantial resonance. The speedy
Courante of this suite nearly
over-matches the instrument, although yet again the Sarabande that follows it is especially impressive. The Gigue that ends this suite and the
entire disc neatly sums up the pluses and minuses of the whole endeavor: it is
rhythmic and very well-played, but lacks the bounce that it has on the cello,
and the wider leaps sound a trifle awkward. This is certainly an interesting
way to hear some familiar Bach music, and clarinetists are sure to enjoy it:
there was no bass clarinet in Bach’s time, but as an experiment in
what-might-have-been, Ranz’s arrangements of these suites are impressively
unusual.
One instrument with a longstanding
association with multiple forms of expressiveness is the piano, and just how
far pianistic moods stretch can be seen, or rather heard, on two recent
releases from MSR Classics. Inna Faliks offers attentive, nuanced and
beautifully balanced readings of major works by both Schumanns, Robert and
Clara, on a CD titled “The Schumann Project, Volume 1” – implying that there
are more such juxtapositions to come. They will be most welcome if they
continue in the same vein as this initial disc. Clara’s G minor sonata dates to
1841-42, but she never played it in public and, indeed, neither did anyone
else. It was not published until as recently as 1991. The very short
third-movement Scherzo did turn up in
her Quatre Pièces Fugitives, Op. 15,
but the rest of the work lay fallow. This is not a great sonata or evidence of
Clara’s full development as a composer – in fact, her development in that vein
remained arrested throughout her lifetime as she focused on performance and on
promoting Robert’s music. However, the sonata is quite well-constructed, its
first movement being the most broadly conceived and its second, slow movement
hinting at emotional connections that it is somewhat too short to convey fully.
The little Scherzo and brisk
concluding Rondo are pleasant if
somewhat superficial; the work as a whole breaks no new ground, but certainly
shows Clara’s ability to create music that is worthwhile both to perform and to
hear. Nevertheless, Robert’s Symphonic
Etudes dominates Faliks’ disc. Largely in variation form – but in the sense
of Beethoven’s Diabelli Variations,
within which the theme is often so transformed as to disappear almost
completely – the Symphonic Etudes
hark back to Bach in their polyphony and use of canonic effects, while existing
fully within the Romantic era through their extended exploration of technique
and of the piano’s ability to become a Lisztian “orchestra in miniature.” Like
most pianists today, Faliks includes the five posthumously published etudes
along with the original 12, placing the first two after Etude III, the third
after Etude V, the fourth after Etude VIII, and the fifth just before the finale
(Etude XII). This arrangement works well, and the inclusion of the posthumous
material broadens the scope of this already-large work even further, resulting
in a performance lasting 34 minutes and exploring, within that time frame,
pretty much all the ups and downs, ins and outs that intrigued Robert early in
his career. The Symphonic Etudes date
to 1834, when Robert was 24 and not yet involved with Clara – in fact, in the
year of this work’s composition, he had been engaged to Ernestine von Fricken,
making her Estrella in his Carnaval.
And it was her father who created the theme on which most of the etudes are
based. There will surely be more obscure-but-fascinating biographical
connections of this sort as Faliks continues juxtaposing works by Robert and
Clara – and hopefully playing them with as much understanding and skill as she
brings to these two.
The piano can, of course, express moods
through miniatures as well as large-scale pieces – in fact, some of the
attraction of the Symphonic Etudes and
similar works comes from their use of small-scale pieces that, in totality,
become part of a larger canvas, the whole being more than the sum of its parts.
In some piano music, though, small pieces are entirely self-contained and are
designed to encapsulate just one feeling, attitude or thought. Elena Casanova
offers a heaping helping of them on a disc called Ensueños de Cuba, which has no fewer than 44 tracks lasting 70
minutes – meaning the average piece here is just about a minute and a half
long. Yet the works are quite evocative within their limited time span – and
all of them speak of Cuba, its history and turmoil and beauty and grace and
above all its dances. Casanova was born in Cuba, and for her this recital is a
tribute to her homeland – but for anyone of any background, it will evoke
feelings of nostalgia and memory even if the specific memories Casanova celebrates
through this material are not a listener’s own. The composers here will
scarcely be household names for a wide audience, with some of them so obscure
that not even their birth and death years are known. They include Ernesto
Lecuona (1895-1963), perhaps the best-known; Miguel Faílde Pérez (1852-1921);
Pedro Garcia (dates unknown); Silvano Boudet (1828-1863); José Fernández de
Coca (dates unknown); Gaspar D. Villate (1851-1891); Felipe B. Valdés (dates
unknown); Jorge Anckermann (1877-1941); Enrique Guerrero (1818-1887); Manuel
Saumell (1818-1870); Maria Matilde Alea (1903-1989); Maria Emma Botet (1903-?);
Harold Gramatges (1918-2008); Andres Alen (born 1950); Cesar Perez Sentenat
(1896-1973); and Rene Touzet (1916-2003). Their works are quite different, but
are united in this recital by their encapsulation within a very short time span
of a single feeling, desire, emotion or hope. Sometimes the time of a work is very short: Botet’s four Dancitas de Ayer last a total of
two-and-a-half minutes – all four combined. Saumell’s Seis Contradanzas are somewhat lengthier, their total time being 12
minutes, but again they give the impression of being here and gone quickly,
leaving only a wisp of melody and feeling behind. The longest work on the disc,
19 minutes, is Alea’s Miniaturas Ritmicas
Cubanas No. 2, but in keeping with the approach of the entire CD, it
contains no fewer than 17 movements. Casanova plays the whole disc with nicely
understated technique, bringing out emotions without laying them on too
thickly, allowing the composers’ evocations of Cuba to flow naturally and
pleasantly from one to the next. The material may be a bit much for non-Cubans
to sit through from start to finish: there is a degree of repetitiveness in the
evoked feelings and, to some extent, in the style of some pieces from similar
time periods. But it is perfectly possible to dip into the disc for a while, go
do something else, and return to it to pick up where you left off – resuming an
evocative musical program that shows the piano’s ability to bring forth a pleasantly
nostalgic set of thoughts, feelings and moods.