Johann Strauss Jr.: Der
Zigeunerbaron. Nikolai Schukoff, Claudia Barainsky, Jochen Schmeckenbecher,
Khatuna Mikaberidze, Heinz Zednik, Markus Brück, Jasmina Sakr, Paul Kaufmann, Renate Pirschneider; NDR Choir
and NDR Radiophilharmonie conducted by Lawrence Foster. PentaTone. $29.99 (2
SACDs).
Antonio Lotti: Missa Sancti
Christophori; Miserere in C minor; Credo in G minor; Dixit Dominus in G minor.
The Syred Consort and Orchestra of St. Paul’s conducted by Ben Palmer.
Delphian. $16.99.
Randall Thompson: Requiem.
The Philadelphia Singers conducted by David Hayes. Naxos. $12.99.
John Rutter: Psalmfest (1993);
This is the day (2011); Lord, Thou has been our refuge (2008); Psalm 150
(2002). Elizabeth Cragg, soprano; Pascal Charbonneau, tenor; Mike Allen,
trumpet; Tom Winpenny, organ; St. Albans Cathedral Choir, Abbey Girls Choir and
Royal Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Andrew Lucas. Naxos. $12.99.
Einojuhani Rautavaara: Rubáiyát
(2015); Into the Heart of Light (Canto V) (2012); Balada (2014); Four Songs
from the Opera “Rasputin” (2012). Gerald Finley, bass-baritone; Mika
Pohjonen, tenor; Helsinki Music Centre Choir; Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra
conducted by John Storgårds. Ondine.
$16.99.
The other Johann Strauss Jr. operetta that merits more than occasional
performance – other than Die Fledermaus,
that is – is Der Zigeunerbaron, an
absurdly plotted and amazingly tuneful mishmash of some of the themes that
Offenbach handled much more pointedly and amusingly in La Grande-Duchesse de Gérolstein nearly two decades earlier. Strauss had
exasperatingly poor luck with libretti; even Die Fledermaus has a third act that is more stage play and melodrama
than operetta – there is little music in it. But listeners who are willing
simply to sit back and revel in the composer’s almost endless tunefulness will
find much to enjoy in PentaTone’s excellent recording of Der Zigeunerbaron, which does the work to a fine turn and manages
to produce convincing characterizations of a number of less-than-admirable
characters. Like Die Fledermaus, a
domestic drama whose protagonists include a revenge-seeker, an utterly bored
Russian prince and a mutually faithless middle-class husband and wife, Der Zigeunerbaron has no really heroic characters.
Sándor
Barinkay (Nikolai Schukoff), the nobleman of the title – not a real nobleman in the work’s context,
since he is merely baron of the
Gypsies – makes a ridiculously abrupt decision to wed a woman he has never
seen, the daughter of his neighbor, a rich but illiterate and self-important
pig farmer, Kálmán Zsupán (Jochen
Schmeckenbecher). The daughter, Arsena (Jasmina Sakr), is in love with someone
else, a nonentity named Ottokar (Paul Kaufmann),and when Barinkay discovers
this, he flies into a rage and abruptly gives his affections to the Gypsy girl
Saffi (Claudia Barainsky). Saffi is the sole human-seeming character in the whole
work – but when it turns out she is of royal blood, Barinkay deserts her and
goes off to war because he does not deserve her, even though he has already
slept with her and (in the work’s most affecting scene) describes having been “married” to her by the forces of
nature. The men march off to war and, when they return, Barinkay is made a real baron and reunited with Saffi, and
arranges for Ottokar and Arsena to wed as well. Hence the happy, if ridiculous,
ending. Hungarian-style music permeates Der
Zigeunerbaron, and Strauss handles it expertly, although the Zigeunerlied here is curiously bloodless
(when compared with, for example, Rosalinde’s faux Hungarian aria in Die
Fledermaus). Barinkay’s entry couplet song is hilarious, however, and the
second-act assertion of being married by nature – which Barinkay and Saffi
deliver together – is genuinely magical. In the third act, the introductory
waltz is wonderfully tuneful, and Zsupán’s bragging about his battlefield
exploits, which consist mostly of stealing dead enemies’ belongings, is amusing
in black-humor manner. The performers, including chorus and orchestra, do an
absolutely first-rate job with this music, and Lawrence Foster paces the
proceedings wonderfully and even assumes the small role of the Herald – who
announces that the war, which takes place offstage, is over – himself. The
underlying, if parodied, militaristic adventuring of Der Zigeunerbaron does not wear very well, and the typecast
characters, Saffi excepted, generate little warmth or sympathy. But this
excellent live recording captures all the high points of the work and glosses
over the lesser ones to good effect. And PentaTone deserves special credit not
only for its usual outstanding sound but also for a picture-perfect
presentation of the two-CD set, with complete German-and-English libretto and
helpful but not overdone booklet notes. The whole package is a thoroughly
winning one.
The contrast
between the froth of Der Zigeunerbaron
and the seriousness of the music of Antonio Lotti (1667-1740) could not be
greater. Lotti is known nowadays only for a single work, an eight-part setting
of the Crucifixus. This is a
beautifully balanced, elegant and emotive handling of the text, certainly
worthy of the frequency with which it is performed. But it lasts less than four
minutes and is in fact just one part of Lotti’s half-hour Missa Sancti Christophori – whose
totality, as heard on a new Delphian CD featuring the Syred Consort and
Orchestra of St. Paul’s under Ben Palmer, is even more impressive and shows
Lotti to be in the first rank of Baroque liturgical composers. And he is more
than that, as the other works on this recording show: Lotti wrote mostly for
Venice’s Basilica of San Marco at a time when extravagance in sacred music was
encouraged, and he took to the tenor of the times wholeheartedly. His forces
are large, often surprisingly so, and the scale of his music surpasses what
listeners will expect from having heard other Baroque church works. Furthermore,
Lotti’s style hints at what is to come after the Baroque era becomes the
Classical: there is true galant music
here, not pervasively but from time to time, and there is a level of emotional
involvement – reflected in often-daring harmonies – that looks ahead by several
decades. The preponderance of minor keys is no mere affectation, either: Lotti
uses them to deepen the emotional connection of the words with listeners, and
he likewise employs sometimes-daring harmonies to highlight elements of the texts
in ways that go well beyond what most listeners familiar with Baroque church
works will expect. The excellently balanced vocal and instrumental ensembles
blend beautifully in this recording, where what comes through is both the
sincerity of the religious messages of the music and the determination of Lotti
to deliver those messages using harmonic and coloristic techniques that push
the bounds of what was generally accepted in his time.
In our own time, pretty much
anything that composers choose to do to emphasize sacred messages can be
acceptable, but that does not prevent certain works from standing out in their
own way. One such is the 1958 Requiem
by Randall Thompson (1899-1984). Thompson is well-known to amateur as well as
professional choirs, and his choral music is often performed – but the Requiem is not, and the new Naxos CD
featuring the Philadelphia Singers under David Hayes is its world première recording. The reason for this
work’s neglect is apparent throughout. Running nearly an hour and requiring two
a cappella choirs with the ability to
handle music of considerable intricacy, the Requiem
opens in anguish and preserves intense emotion all the way through – dispensing
with the traditional Latin Requiem Mass and instead using strung-together texts
from various books of the Bible, grouped by Thompson into five sections called
“Lamentations,” “The Triumph of Faith,” “The Call to Song,” “The Garment of
Praise,” and “The Leave-taking.” Passing references to the works of earlier
composers abound here, but there is nothing overtly imitative in what Thompson
has done. Instead, references to Bach in “Lamentations,” Beethoven’s Ninth
Symphony in “The Call to Song,” Handel in “The Garment of Praise,” and
Beethoven’s Missa Solemnis (in mood,
not any specific music) at the end of “The Leave-taking” all serve to place Thompson’s
Requiem firmly in line with the works
of earlier composers – without ever making it seem beholden to the past. Indeed,
Thompson sometimes reaches back to even before the age of Antonio Lotti, using
textual repetition in a way that harks back to Gregorian chant. This Requiem is a work of considerable
substance, performed sensitively and even elegantly by singers and a conductor
who spent two years preparing the full work for performance and this recording.
Their care shows in the meticulous attention to detail that is evident all
through a piece that is deeply involving from start to finish.
John Rutter’s liturgical
works get performances of equally high quality on another Naxos CD, with the
longest piece here by far, Psalmfest,
being another world première
recording. Like many earlier composers, Rutter (born 1945) was inspired by the
psalms of David to create music expressing a wide array of emotions through a
great variety of vocal and instrumental combinations. Rutter sets nine texts in
Psalmfest: the first three are for
chorus and orchestra, the fourth adding solo soprano and tenor, the fifth being
for chorus only, the sixth again for chorus and orchestra with solo soprano and
tenor, the seventh for chorus and orchestra, the eighth for soprano and tenor
with orchestra (but without chorus), the ninth for chorus and orchestra. Rutter
has striven mightily and for the most part successfully to match the performing
forces to the emotional content of the words, which are taken, respectively,
from Psalms 100, 121, 146, 23 (the ubiquitous “The Lord Is My Shepherd”), 96,
27, 47, 84 and 148. Rutter is particularly effective in evoking the contrasting
emotions of, for example, Psalms 121 (“I will lift up mine eyes”) and 47 (“O
clap your hands”). Andrew Lucas leads the performers, vocal and orchestral
alike, with determination, a fine sense of pace, and sensitive awareness of
Rutter’s orchestral colorations and rhythmic contrasts. And the disc is filled
out with material that, far from being “filler,” further shows Rutter’s skill
in handling psalm settings for special occasions. This is the day, for chorus and orchestra, was heard worldwide: it
was composed by Rutter for the wedding of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge in
2011. Lord, Thou has been our refuge (for
chorus, trumpet and organ) and Psalm 150
(for chorus, organ and orchestra), both occasional works as well, are equally
effective in bringing forth their texts clearly while reflecting the emotional
underpinning of the words through Rutter’s skillful vocal settings.
Finland’s greatest living
composer, Einojuhani Rautavaara (born 1928), also shows considerable skill and
variety in the vocal works collected on a new Ondine CD. Rautavaara is more
inclined to mysticism than to traditional religion such as the Psalms, and this
CD shows him using his skill in the service of purely secular material as well
as some with spiritual implications and leanings. Here too are world première recordings – of all four works on
the disc. Rubáiyát,
written for Gerald Finley, who performs it here, is a nine-movement song cycle
that draws on the poetry of Omar Khayyam (1048-1131) – the best-known lines of
which are, in Edward Fitzgerald’s translation, “A book of verses underneath the
bough,/ A jug of wine, a loaf of bread—and thou/ Beside me singing in the
wilderness—/ oh wilderness were paradise enow!” This is elegant love poetry,
and Rautavaara’s setting of it is by turns emotive, sensuous and rather
matter-of-fact. This voice-and-orchestra piece is followed by one written
purely for strings: Into the Heart of
Light (Canto V), which, as the title indicates, is the fifth in a series of
works for string orchestra that Rautavaara has been writing since the 1960s. He
intends each to represent his current compositional techniques and
inclinations, which nowadays mix varying amounts of contemporary compositional
techniques with the Romanticism that dominated in Rautavaara’s work for a time
and to which he often returns. The other two pieces here are again in the
voice-and-orchestra milieu. Balada
sets texts by Federico García Lorca (1898-1936) for tenor, mixed
choir and orchestra, creating a single-movement cantata (almost as long as the
nine movements of Rubáiyát)
that was first performed in Madrid only last year. Finally here are Four Songs from the Opera “Rasputin,”
Rautavaara’s most-recent opera (2001-03). These are dramatic, intense works
that the composer arranged for mixed choir and orchestra nearly a decade after
completing the opera from which they are drawn. They stand effectively on their
own in this impressive arrangement and, in fact, may make listeners more eager
to see and hear the opera itself. The Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra under
John Storgårds has performed
and recorded a considerable amount of Rautavaara’s music, always handling it
with a sure sense of style and a strong commitment to the underlying emotional
content that Rautavaara presents no matter what his stylistic preferences of the
moment may be. This disc is no exception: it is well-played, well-sung and
thoroughly convincing.